UK healthcare professionals received this information called "REG 174 INFORMATION FOR UK HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONALS" [1] It states that the "efficacy of COVID-19 mRNA Vaccine BNT162b2 [for 75 years of age and older] was [...] 100% (two-sided 95% confidence interval of -13.1% to 100.0%)"
What does this mean? With my very minimal university statistics knowledge I would say that they are 95% sure that the efficacy lies between -13.1% and 100.0% for age >=75. And that means: We simply do not know (probably due to lack of data in this cohort). Where am I making an error?
Thank you in advance!
[1] https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/...
I believe you are right in saying we simply don't know what the efficacy is for those over 75 as a result of this study. Given that the range extends to 100% that tells us that no one over 75 who received the vaccine also tested positive for the virus. However the lower bound tells us that even if the vaccine had increased the chance of being infected by 13% we still would have expected 0 over 75 to be infected by the time they were tested simply because the probability of being infected is already so low.
There isn't enough evidence yet to understand whether the leading vaccines induce sterilising immunity yet. As such, we can't rely on these vaccines to give us herd immunity.
THIS IS NOT SOFTWARE! I cannot believe I continue to see this complete ignorance smugly repeated on HN. The vaccine has undergone three phases of testing including large scale release. It's been "baked" since January, the only things fine tuned have been the exact dose of the mRNA. Given the effectiveness, it's highly unlikely we'll see a v1.1 anytime soon, if ever, but if we do it would likely have to go through similar levels of testing and would be just as "pre-alpha" as this.
> On top of it you still have to wear the mask it doesn't stop you spreading the virus.
Other comments have already dealt with why we'll still need to use masks.
> it doesn't stop you spreading the virus. It just reduces the severity for the people vaccinated.
We're still waiting on final data on how much vaccinated people will decrease the spread, but everything we've seen so far indicates that eventual severity of illness correlates very closely with how likely you are to infect others. Even if this wasn't true, reducing severity is huge since universal vaccination would then allow the virus to spread with reduced health effects savings hundreds of thousands of lives.
Don't worry though, what is likely the "average" HN reader (30, male), is pretty much last on the list, so by the time we get it there will be tens or hundreds of millions of people who have received all of the various types of vaccines.
This is the most nonsensical part to me. If the vaccine does what they say it does (reduce severe cases) then the justification for mask wearing and social distancing is gone.
I would consider this faulty logic. I'm going to avoid taking a coronavirus vaccine until we have some actual data on the effects. Why would you rush to risk unknown consequences to your own health, and thus your ability to care for your loved ones if they get sick?
>over many months
Long-term effects have not been investigated. In fact, Pfizer has requested immunity from governments (https://www.independent.co.uk/news/health/coronavirus-pfizer...).
>Asked about when the full data on the vaccine’s clinical trial would be published, the company said this was still being worked on.
Not being able to review this yourself also removes some credibility from that vaccine.
I'm not against fast-forwarding the vaccine to protect the vulnerable, but it's irresponsible to claim this vaccine has insane amounts of data showing its lack of side effects. A better argument would be "it probably is better than getting Covid."
It also highlights the need for everyone to get vaccinated as quickly as possible. Don't procrastinate when the opportunity arises, because there are people around you who can't be vaccinated or can't be vaccinated with vaccines available to them. You being vaccinated cuts off one more path the virus can take to them.