Re:Intel released OpenCL 1.1 for Linux
by andrewcooke on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @06:48AM
(#2535905)
i do! i write custom code for a small "consultancy" in geophysics (we're a handful of people from academia that somehow ended up developing software for people - and it doesn't really have to be geophysics, that's just where we started...).
my most successful project was an inverse problem for mining - taking a bunch of seismic traces and, from that, calculating a 3d map of the source structure (microseismicity - this technique is called SET (seismic emission tomography)). there's an abstract here - http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2010AGUFMIN41A1352D (if anyone wants i can send them the poster, if i can find it!).
incidentally, the AMD OpenCL implementation worked fine on Intel processors already (and has done for a year or so now). i made some notes at http://www.acooke.org/cute/Developing0.html
it's very similar to cuda, but has a couple of advantages. first, it's really well supported on macs. second you aren't stuck with nvidia's hardware (their support is terrible - had a client stuck waiting on results for weeks because they wouldn't respond to issues that eventually turned out to be a failed board). the main disadvantage is that the associated tools/libs aren't as mature.
and a final piece of advice - if you have a finite budget, and don't need 64bit support, you get way better performance per $ using average gaming cards rather than their top-end GPU hardware (although i suspect we'll try out amazon's gpu cloud stuff soon and avoid our own hardware for projects that don't have huge data sets).
my most successful project was an inverse problem for mining - taking a bunch of seismic traces and, from that, calculating a 3d map of the source structure (microseismicity - this technique is called SET (seismic emission tomography)). there's an abstract here - http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2010AGUFMIN41A1352D (if anyone wants i can send them the poster, if i can find it!).
incidentally, the AMD OpenCL implementation worked fine on Intel processors already (and has done for a year or so now). i made some notes at http://www.acooke.org/cute/Developing0.html
it's very similar to cuda, but has a couple of advantages. first, it's really well supported on macs. second you aren't stuck with nvidia's hardware (their support is terrible - had a client stuck waiting on results for weeks because they wouldn't respond to issues that eventually turned out to be a failed board). the main disadvantage is that the associated tools/libs aren't as mature.
and a final piece of advice - if you have a finite budget, and don't need 64bit support, you get way better performance per $ using average gaming cards rather than their top-end GPU hardware (although i suspect we'll try out amazon's gpu cloud stuff soon and avoid our own hardware for projects that don't have huge data sets).