News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Law Enforcement Is Accessing Locked Devices by pdimitar on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @09:39AM (#25358894)
None of us here has anything actually illegal to hide IMO.

Political climate and affiliations change however. What was quite fine and protected by freedom of speech today can be declared illegal by an oppressive government tomorrow. In a situation like this you definitely don't want to have your personal data gathered as easily.

Re:Law Enforcement Is Accessing Locked Devices by throwaway0a5e on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @10:09AM (#25359234)
>What was quite fine and protected by freedom of speech today can be declared illegal by an oppressive government tomorrow.

"declared career-ruining by Twitter" is just as likely IMO.

Whether you're the subject of a public or private witch hunt doesn't really matter if the end result is the same.

Re:Law Enforcement Is Accessing Locked Devices by a1369209993 on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @04:02PM (#25364929)
To be fair, random assholes on Twitter are much less likely to have nation-state-level resources with which to investigate you, so the threat model is a bit different for one type of witch hunt versus the other.
Re:Law Enforcement Is Accessing Locked Devices by pdimitar on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @10:13AM (#25359283)
Yep, sadly you are right and that has been happening quite a bit as well.
Re:Law Enforcement Is Accessing Locked Devices by SkyBelow on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @12:10PM (#25360854)
>None of us here has anything actually illegal to hide IMO.

If they can break your encryption, they can add the illegal stuff that was clearly yours to begin with. Works great as a character assassination. And of course any questions about such incidents would be dismissed as conspiracy theories.

As for how society would react to such a setup? I think the guy involved in 3d printing guns gives a close enough example.

Re:Law Enforcement Is Accessing Locked Devices by jbob2000 on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @09:44AM (#25358936)
But that’s my point. If the circumstances change such that the people in power want you dead, they don’t need your hard drives. They’ll just kill you.
Re:Law Enforcement Is Accessing Locked Devices by jtbayly on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @09:49AM (#25358992)
Only if they already know they want you dead. The whole point of this discussion is protecting your data from them so they don’t know that.
Re:Law Enforcement Is Accessing Locked Devices by pdonis on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @10:48AM (#25359770)
This has little, if anything, to do with protecting the data on your phone. You would have to never post any information anywhere on the Internet.
Re:Law Enforcement Is Accessing Locked Devices by jtbayly on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @11:53AM (#25360662)
"Private" communication exists using the Internet. Sometimes your device is in custody because you are in custody for suspicions they already have. In which case, good luck. Other times your device is in custody just because you happen to be crossing a border, for example. In that case, having the device be actually locked might prevent you from being turned away at the border or even ending up in custody yourself.
Re:Law Enforcement Is Accessing Locked Devices by pdonis on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @03:55PM (#25364778)
> "Private" communication exists using the Internet.

Sure, but virtually nobody depends on it to protect the sort of data that you are worried about if you're worried about an oppressive regime deciding to persecute you for what you say. For example, if you're afraid something you post on HN might cause an oppressive regime to come after you, securing your phone, or for that matter your laptop or desktop, isn't going to help you at all. Same goes for pretty much any place people say things on the Internet. Unless you never say anything except in a private, locked chat room secured by unbreakable encryption, and never send any email to anyone without using PGP and without being certain that they are also taking the same precautions you are, anything you say on the Internet is out there for the finding if anyone gets interested enough in you to look.

Re:Law Enforcement Is Accessing Locked Devices by jtbayly on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @06:50PM (#25367280)
Signal is incredibly easy to use and many people use it. It’s easy to limit sensitive things to a medium like that. It’s also easy to create profiles that are some degree of “anonymous” that you can use for semi-sensitive data.

You don’t have to resort to never using the Internet as you imply. The vast majority of things people do online are perfectly safe for you to do, even if you are a potential target of a government.

Re:Law Enforcement Is Accessing Locked Devices by pdonis on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @07:28PM (#25367735)
> Signal is incredibly easy to use and many people use it.

For particular kinds of communication, yes.

> It’s easy to limit sensitive things to a medium like that.

It's possible, I suppose, but I would not say it's easy. People want to do many, many different things online. Signal only facilitates a tiny fraction of them. Most people won't be willing to limit their activities online so drastically.

> The vast majority of things people do online are perfectly safe for you to do, even if you are a potential target of a government.

Either you have a particularly limited set of online activities you engage in, or you are drastically underestimating the lengths to which governments will go if they become sufficiently oppressive.

Re:Law Enforcement Is Accessing Locked Devices by pdimitar on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @09:57AM (#25359091)
Fair enough, but that's not my point. My point was more about persecution, not outright killings. That's an extreme that many governments won't reach for, even in the third world.