I got S(I)(I)(I)(4) to return 4, everything else is errors.

> TypeError: 'int' object is not callable

Heh, yeah I did that too when I was wrapping my head around 'em. The thing to remember is that in SKI combinator logic nothing else exists. You can't pass 'int' objects to SKI because they don't exist in that universe. (Obviously you can in the sense that Python will let you do it, but it's logically meaningless.)

(I had to break out pencil and paper and walk through some evaluations of SKI expressions by hand.)

Let's have versions of I that also print their names and arg as a side effect:

    def E(x):
        print('E', x)
        return x

    def F(x):
        print('F', x)
        return x

    def G(x):
        print('G', x)
        return x

Consider:

    S(E)(F)

Start with the definition of S:

    S = lambda x: lambda y: lambda z: x(z)(y(z))

Substitute:

    S = lambda E: lambda y: lambda z: E(z)(y(z))

So now S returns this new function (call it S') that has the E function embedded in the closure:

    S' = lambda y: lambda z: E(z)(y(z))

That gets called on F:

    S'(F)

Substitute:

    S' = lambda F: lambda z: E(z)(F(z))

And this creates S'' with both E and F embedded:

    S'' = lambda z: E(z)(F(z))

So the result is a function that takes some function z, calls F on it, calls G on it, and then calls the result of the first on the result of the second.

    S''(G)

    E(G)(F(G))
                E(G) -> G ; prints "E <function G at 0x000001E0A4A741F0>"
       G(F(G))
                F(G) -> G ; prints "F <function G at 0x000001E0A4A741F0>"
       G(G)
                prints "G <function G at 0x000001E0A4A741F0>"
         G  <--- G returns itself.

In action:

    In [16]: S(E)(F)
    Out[16]: <function __main__.<lambda>.<locals>.<lambda>.<locals>.<lambda>(z)>

    In [17]: S(E)(F)(G)
    E <function G at 0x000001E0A4A741F0>
    F <function G at 0x000001E0A4A741F0>
    G <function G at 0x000001E0A4A741F0>
    Out[17]: <function __main__.G(x)>

Since G is also a version of I we can get away with passing it anything (not just functions):

    In [18]: S(E)(F)(G)("Hi!")
    E <function G at 0x000001E0A4A741F0>
    F <function G at 0x000001E0A4A741F0>
    G <function G at 0x000001E0A4A741F0>
    G Hi!
    Out[18]: 'Hi!'

That's why you can pass anything to SIII (aka S(I)(I)(I) in Python) and it returns it, because SIII = I.

    In [19]: S(I)(I)(I) is I
    Out[19]: True

HTH