News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Brief History of Dangerous Ideas by stcredzero on Tuesday July 22, 2008 @02:24PM (#253504)
Hmm, why is the iPod/iPhone counted as only one idea? There's a lot of strong arguments for counting them as two. Especially interesting since the number comparison is made to Miles Davis who is said to have 5 ideas.
Re:A Brief History of Dangerous Ideas by raganwald on Tuesday July 22, 2008 @03:30PM (#253556)
take your pick:

1. iPod Touch/iPhone is like a Macintosh, only smaller; 2. iPod Touch/iPhone is like an iPod, only more sophisticated; 3. iPod Touch/iPhone has something in common with a Macintosh and an iPod, but it is its own device in its own category, it transcends its parents.

If you go with #3, it deserves its own number.

I had to leave a lot of ranting out, but if you're looking for more material, I actually consider iTunes to be the strongest candidate for another Jobs-led hit. It is dangerous in its own right, and the music industry seems to hate it almost as much as they hated the "rip. mix. burn." ads for iMacs.

Re:A Brief History of Dangerous Ideas by stcredzero on Wednesday July 23, 2008 @09:46AM (#254304)
In that case, I think you really need to give at least "the tie" to Steve. Not only does #3 sound the best, but you just argued him another point for iTunes.
Re:A Brief History of Dangerous Ideas by raganwald on Wednesday July 23, 2008 @10:37AM (#254348)
Re:A Brief History of Dangerous Ideas by stcredzero on Wednesday July 23, 2008 @02:13PM (#254572)
Just because you're being subtle doesn't make you any less rude.

Perhaps a better argument against: Are all dangerous ideas of equal value? How would you compare a reinvention of Jazz with iTunes? (A more polished and legal replacement of the original Napster.)

Ah, I see now. You meant the score as just a tongue in cheek thing.

Re:A Brief History of Dangerous Ideas by raganwald on Wednesday July 23, 2008 @02:32PM (#254604)
I absolutely meant the score as a tongue-in-cheek thing, which is why I tried to keep my response to you in the same spirit. I had no intention to offend!

Outside of having a laugh--supposedly at Steve's expense--I wouldn't try to compare the two men in any serious way.