All that said, I've recently done a couple of months of programming (in a very restrictive environment) in Javascript, and I yearn for a compiler.
Perhaps these tools do help "losers lose less"... but a tool is a force multiplier (bad tools are multipliers with a value less than one, and truly bad tools have negative multipliers :D Not all tools are bad.)
In the hands of an expert, the right tool can become a powerful weapon.
Really? In every aspect of programming? In every language? This is the typical prima donna bullshit that pervades this industry. I pity anyone who has to deal with you on a daily basis.
So I think your "truly bad tools" don't exist.
Good point.
Whatever tools we can leverage to make us lose less should be welcomed with open arms.
That's true in the abstract. In reality, though, there are often tradeoffs that come with these safeguards.
Remember, this was written in 2002. Scala wasn't around, C# was just invented, and neither Ruby nor Python were in popular use.
While I grant that that's a harsh statement, would you disagree with what he says next?
"Our current popular languages are designed to help losers lose less."