Re:Mysterious black spot in polar explorer's diary offers gr...
by xarope on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @04:11AM
(#25343334)
You can, actually (I've used a soto windmaster in deep snow around 6000+m before). It's "just" a question of ensuring the canister itself stays warm enough (e.g. warm it up in your jacket before use, put in a bowl of water, or welding some sort of metal to the stove to conduct the heat back to the canister.. the last which I have NEVER done, since I've read about all sorts of explosion-likely events!)
Re:Mysterious black spot in polar explorer's diary offers gr...
by ashtonkem on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @09:59AM
(#25345988)
There are also some stoves that can run Isopro through the same heating cycle that Kerosene and Naptha go through, theoretically allowing you to use Isopro below its vaporization point. My MSR Whisperlite Universal can do that by simply inverting the Isopro canister (it also runs right-side up in warmer weather), but personally I’d opt for white gas if I was going anywhere near Isopro’s failure temperatures, just to be safe.
Sad to say some manufacturers, and thus camping magazines and web sites, do recommend canister stoves for winter camping (cough looking at you, snow peak, though you are not alone). I'm surprised they haven't killed anyone -- perhaps they are used by people who stay close to their vehicles. Those canisters are heavy and have to be packed out and discarded.
Liquid stoves have other tradeoffs but are much more reliable at all inhabitable altitudes. They are good at temperatures I can deal with at least as I try never to travel overland below -10 F -- I know some do but I simply don't believe I have the skills.
Another problem with the inexpensive canister stoves is, surprisingly, their tolerances. We had a jetboil fail in the Australian desert -- some grit simply got where it shouldn't. Bit of a crisis. A dragonfly or something like that is more tolerant of expanding, contracting, getting unfortunate bits in it (and being cleanable).