Don't jump to conclusion too fast.
Enable safethreading and you will likely go to 2 or 3 instances, due to the many small requests you have. You may even go to 1 or 2 instances when they have finished optimizing their scheduler. So who knows, you may even end up with a lower monthly bill!!
We currently pay about $0.60 a day, so $18 a month
On the new system we have 25 instances on average so 24 * 25 * 0.08 = $48 a day or $1440 a month, even with reserved instances this is $900 a month, a x50 increase....
We do thousands of small requests, optimized for low CPU usage and not instance count, guess its time to move.