News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Let’s mug a startup founder by tptacek on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @03:38PM (#2533805)
Ryan, I assure you that in the US, a typical startup founder cannot walk into the bank and leave with an unsecured $163,000 loan. Businesses with many multiples of that in top-line revenue can't get that loan without personal liability.

I probably agree that 6% PLUS a $32k (zero-interest) loan is not a good deal.

But I don't even think 6% for ~$20k is a good deal for funding.

I don't think the comparison you're making here is fair. Calling it a "mugging" is a bit over the top. The people who mug startups are consultants and do-nothing executive hires.

Re:Let’s mug a startup founder by ryancarson on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @03:52PM (#2533861)
The typical lean web startup doesn't need £100,000 as seed funding. I mentioned our 0% equity loan because it demonstrates what a terrible deal this accelerator is offering.
Re:Let’s mug a startup founder by tptacek on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @04:00PM (#2533884)
Loans and lines of credit often don't require equity. They frequently do require you to put up your house. You cannot pull an interest-free loan, backed only by your corporation, off a tree. It is a real offering. It is not reasonable to call it a "mugging".

We agree on how valuable $32k of seed money (debt or equity) is worth. To wit: not much.

We agree on how expensive 6% of your company is worth. To wit: a deceptively large amount.

We agree that this seed program is probably not a good deal.

I just think there's a difference between "probably not worth it" and "bad virtually to the point of criminality", which is what the wording you used meant.

Re:Let’s mug a startup founder by ryancarson on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @04:29PM (#2533967)
Mark, the guy behind this accelerator, sold his company for multiple millions. Are you suggesting he doesn't have the business experience to see this for the bad deal it is?
Re:Let’s mug a startup founder by tptacek on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @04:32PM (#2533982)
It is hard for me to argue this with you, because I agree that 6% is a steep price to pay for any favor, be it an interest-free unsecured loan or a $20k seed investment.

But that's a subjective point.

What's not subjective is that an interest-free unsecured loan for $32k USD IS a favor, not a mugging, and while I don't think it's worth 6%, or even 1%, it's not right for me to accuse the offerer of that loan of mendacity.

A question I'd put back to you:

Assume that there is no seed fund or accelerator program you can get to accept you, other than this one. Assume that you need the $32k; stipulate that you cannot, say, bootstrap or consult your way out of the first 6 months living expenses.

Would you advise someone not to start a company instead of accepting this deal?

Re:Let’s mug a startup founder by ryancarson on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @05:38PM (#2534191)
Your question highlights the fundamental problem. All the hype about acquisitions of young startups, funded by seed programs, has created some sort of widely held belief that you have to participate in an accelerator to launch a startup.

It's also causing investors to be more aggressive in pushing their money on startups, whether they need it or not. Inexperienced startup founders will mistake their fervor as an indication that they should take the money, instead of an indication that maybe their startup has real potential and they should be slower to give part of it away.

"Would you advise someone not to start a company instead of accepting this deal?"

That's a false dichotomy. There are plenty of companies (ours, 37signals, etc) that started without any funding at all. Then when we decided to raise funding (debt in our case), it was easy to get because we had real revenue and clear growth. It made sense for the bank to loan money to us because it could see we that we were going to pay it back.

Let's all stop spreading this bizarre myth that you have to take part in an accelerator to start a company.

Re:Let’s mug a startup founder by tptacek on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @06:10PM (#2534278)
If you ask, you'll find that there are few on HN louder and more obnoxious about skipping external funding than me. We bootstrapped in 2005. Not getting funding: best thing that ever happened to us.

But it's one thing to have it in for all seed funding programs (I'm with you on that!) and another to call one specific one "muggers" because you particularly don't like their terms. At least, not with terms like these.

Finally, just out of curiosity: is your $162k debt financing secured solely with your corporation? You didn't have to provide any collateral, or any personal guarantees? Obviously: I don't think you could pull that off in the US. Unless your revenues are way higher than I assume they are (my current assumption is already pretty high).