News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Macs with T2, M1 chips cannot be restored to factory stat... by gruez on Sunday December 06, 2020 @12:07AM (#25321203)
The key words missing from the title is "without _connection to_ apple". From the original title I assumed that you had to take it to the apple store to reset it or something.
Re:Macs with T2, M1 chips cannot be restored to factory stat... by Zenst on Sunday December 06, 2020 @12:28AM (#25321314)
Which is good from the aspect that if your device is stolen or lost, the finder/thief just can't factory reset it and use it.
Re:Macs with T2, M1 chips cannot be restored to factory stat... by fastball on Sunday December 06, 2020 @12:30AM (#25321330)
Which is exactly why they do it.

Actual customers that buy lots of Apple products and have appreciated how every year iPhones get more and more pointless to steal have been asking for the same for their laptops for years.

Re:Macs with T2, M1 chips cannot be restored to factory stat... by usrusr on Sunday December 06, 2020 @01:35AM (#25321631)
Well, one could solve that just as well with a device that is fully open to the owner and still pointless to steal. By handing out a per-device master reset key that the owner doesn't need for regular operation and thus doesn't have with the device when and where someone might want to steal it.
Re:Macs with T2, M1 chips cannot be restored to factory stat... by Someone on Sunday December 06, 2020 @05:38AM (#25322609)
That wouldn’t work for quite a few users. They would lose the reset key and be locked out of their hardware.

I think Apple should offer users the option, though, just as they for account recovery (https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT208072. I’m not sure that works without _also_ going to Apple’s servers)

Re:Macs with T2, M1 chips cannot be restored to factory stat... by smichel17 on Sunday December 06, 2020 @11:19AM (#25324437)
I don't see why the key couldn't optionally be stored with Apple, or even by default. But it should be possible/easy to manage your key yourself if you want.
Re:Macs with T2, M1 chips cannot be restored to factory stat... by tomjen3 on Sunday December 06, 2020 @05:35AM (#25322591)
If you don't have to use them regularly then people will misplace them.
Re:Macs with T2, M1 chips cannot be restored to factory stat... by imtringued on Sunday December 06, 2020 @07:05AM (#25322981)
Apple can still offer an internet based factory reset in addition to the offline factory reset.
Re:Macs with T2, M1 chips cannot be restored to factory stat... by spease on Sunday December 06, 2020 @04:16AM (#25322239)
They could, but open source has a poor track record of making an easy solution for something this comprehensive that a regular user can set up.
Re:Macs with T2, M1 chips cannot be restored to factory stat... by Wowfunhappy on Sunday December 06, 2020 @01:07AM (#25321504)
That makes sense if Activation Lock is turned on. But you should be able to turn it off if you need a fully offline machine.
Re:Macs with T2, M1 chips cannot be restored to factory stat... by Out_of_Characte on Sunday December 06, 2020 @04:03AM (#25322180)
You never needed apple for that. My laptop can't just be 'factory reset' because the thief would have to flash the bios. without that something as simple as secureboot will prevent reinstalling a different OS.
Re:Macs with T2, M1 chips cannot be restored to factory stat... by userbinator on Sunday December 06, 2020 @12:35AM (#25321364)
How is that good? Nearly all other non-electronic products behave based on the fact that the one in physical possession of it is the owner, and that is a notion which has lasted for literally millenia.

Make no mistake, this is simply Apple's attempt to gain complete control over its users.

Re:Macs with T2, M1 chips cannot be restored to factory stat... by rsanheim on Sunday December 06, 2020 @12:56AM (#25321461)
> Make no mistake, this is simply Apple's attempt to gain complete control over its users.

This is unfair and just not true.

It is known that apple products can be rendered useless after being stolen easily by the original owner. Yes, they still get stolen, but it is a really nice feature that you can wipe the data remotely and mark the device as lost / stolen. You also know the thief will mostly be stuck with a low-value device that is all but useless without some sort of jailbreak or scam to resell it.

Of course, this feature has tradeoffs, and some of them are negative for some people (like the OP sneak). Maybe it helps Apple "gain complete control" over users, but you are gonna need more evidence to support that claim.

To completely ignore the positive aspects is not contributing anything at all w/ these sorts of discussion.

Re:Macs with T2, M1 chips cannot be restored to factory stat... by webmobdev on Sunday December 06, 2020 @09:30AM (#25323663)
> You also know the thief will mostly be stuck with a low-value device that is all but useless without some sort of jailbreak or scam to resell it.

(1) Jailbreak is a feature for many who consider it a way to free their iDevices from Apples's iron clutches.

(2) And I used to think too that remote locking the device makes it less viable for thieves. Turns out that's a fallacy because they are doing what some automobile theives do now - strip it and sell the parts. (And thanks to Apple's exorbitant prices for its parts and suing most "unauthorized" sellers / suppliers, that's a lucrative market too.)

Re:Macs with T2, M1 chips cannot be restored to factory stat... by userbinator on Sunday December 06, 2020 @01:07AM (#25321505)
Maybe it helps Apple "gain complete control" over users, but you are gonna need more evidence to support that claim.

The claims made in the article and their long history of locking down their systems against the user and fighting right-to-repair aren't enough evidence? Apple wants you to consume when they tell you to, and if you don't they can simply brick your hardware and leave you SOL.

Re:Macs with T2, M1 chips cannot be restored to factory stat... by rsanheim on Sunday December 06, 2020 @02:16AM (#25321778)
my point was that its not that simple, and you sound like a zealot. Apple's main focus has always been about creating an amazing experience for humans via Apple computers and devices. Thats it. The hardware is secondary and the expandability is secondary. How that has played has changed over time and depending on the context (ex: the original Mac Pro or even the first Macs), but allowing someone to add all the ram and storage has never been at the forefront of apple's vision.

There are clearly billions of people who are okay with giving up 'control' over their devices and data, whether its apple or amazon or google. I know my windows machine nags me every time I restart to phone home to MS and setup some account, and that's not even a reinstall. My android device asks for a google login at like step 3 of the setup process. Sure, I can bypass it, cuz I don't care and they aren't my primary machines, but most people will not.

Most people don't care if their laptop or phone phones home when it needs to be reset, as long as it works and makes them happy. Most people (I would guess 99%+) don't repair their devices beyond fixing a cracked screen or maybe adding RAM or a new GPU to a prebuilt gaming PC. How many folks can even dismantle and work on a modern phone with any success, whether Android or iOS?

Some people think about privacy and ads and surveillance wrt technology. I know I do. I see that Apple does things that can serve multiple interests at the same time, and it isn't so black and white:

* they want to sell a shit load of services and hardware and continue to make crazy amounts of money

* they see that privacy is slowly (but surely) becoming a thing people want, especially those w/ the dollars and more tech savvy. So they are focusing on privacy with their products, and that is real. No matter how much apple haters love to call out counter examples, they are making a real effort - look at Siri and iMessage and Apple Maps.

* they also want do deliver an amazing experience to people - I know I don't need to explain how security and user experience are often in conflict.

Ignoring all these factors at play here is missing the bigger picture.

Re:Macs with T2, M1 chips cannot be restored to factory stat... by cmckn on Sunday December 06, 2020 @01:00AM (#25321475)
What control am I really losing here? There isn’t a way to implement this specific security measure without a remote service, so Apple provides the remote service. I get the security feature.
Re:Macs with T2, M1 chips cannot be restored to factory stat... by imtringued on Sunday December 06, 2020 @07:07AM (#25322985)
Other HN commenters have said that an optional offline factory reset is possible by providing a device specific password/master key. The fact that Apple only provides internet based recovery means they don't care about user control.
Re:Macs with T2, M1 chips cannot be restored to factory stat... by Spooky23 on Sunday December 06, 2020 @12:45AM (#25321412)
Try getting a car key replaced sometime. Both my car key and my wife’s were in the same bag when they fell out of a capsized canoe and sunk. Not fun nor cheap.

I don’t like it, but the market wants crap like this.

Re:Macs with T2, M1 chips cannot be restored to factory stat... by edoceo on Sunday December 06, 2020 @01:12AM (#25321526)
Or, the market pushback isn't loud enough. (Or financially significant)
Re:Macs with T2, M1 chips cannot be restored to factory stat... by rStar on Sunday December 06, 2020 @02:19PM (#25325868)
apple is a cell phone company now. in the same way that users in the US hate Verizon, ATT etc for rubbing our noses in the fact that we have no choice but to use their service, which frees them up to treat us, the customer, like trash, that’s how anyone paying attention and being honest with themselves now feels about apple. there’s not a sliver of sunlight of a difference between these corporations, and in fact, they enable one another. I wish this weren’t the case, and even if apple didn’t have sycophants populating 80% of this message board it wouldn’t matter. they are beyond having to give a crap about users, technically inclined or otherwise, at this point.
Re:Macs with T2, M1 chips cannot be restored to factory stat... by danielheath on Sunday December 06, 2020 @03:24AM (#25322019)
I mean, that sucks, but surely getting your car stolen sucks considerably more, right?

How much less likely do these technologies have to make theft before the hassle to actual owners isn’t worth it?

Re:Macs with T2, M1 chips cannot be restored to factory stat... by Spooky23 on Sunday December 06, 2020 @10:46AM (#25324212)
It does — as does getting mugged for your $1200 phone!
Re:Macs with T2, M1 chips cannot be restored to factory stat... by boardwaalk on Sunday December 06, 2020 @01:00AM (#25321474)
I don't not agree with your sentiment, but responding with "How is that good?" to “the finder/thief just can't factory reset it and use it” seems like you’re not actually responding to what they said.
Re:Macs with T2, M1 chips cannot be restored to factory stat... by dodobirdlord on Sunday December 06, 2020 @12:39AM (#25321384)
Containers with locks have existed for a very long time.
Re:Macs with T2, M1 chips cannot be restored to factory stat... by Keverw on Sunday December 06, 2020 @12:26AM (#25321301)
Yeah, that's what I was thinking from the title too. I guess it's because of the activation lock feature, no different than a iPhone or iPad.