News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Erosion of Deep Literacy by DubiousPusher on Saturday December 05, 2020 @03:36AM (#25312874)
This article makes far reaching societal claims with essentially no evidence. The evidence presented is in the form of "feelings" of various writers concerned of their own decline in literaryfocus.

An unvoiced assumption that people were historically more literate pervades the entire article. As a former lit. major I used to buy into this kind of thing. But I now think this belief is the product of profound selection bias. Literature and history libraries are full of the very best diaries and letters of the very best diary and letter writers because those are enjoyable to read and being more detailed are more useful. History is not written by the victors but by the literate.

People of letters that write this kind of article are obviously inclined towards letters and therefore inclined to sample history through literate means and therefore greatly overestimate the literacy of the past.

But let us pair anecdote to anecdote. There is a podcast network called "The New Books Network". It examines weekly the release of new academic works. It began as "New Books in History" covering one new history book each week. Now it features dozens of podcasts each covering a new book every week. Engage these podcasts for six months and at the end, tell where your biases lie. You will probably suddenly believe we live in the most literate age of all.

Re:The Erosion of Deep Literacy by keiferski on Saturday December 05, 2020 @05:05AM (#25313257)
The issue isn't whether there are abundant "literate" resources (podcasts, in your example) but whether the average member of a democratic society is literate. More importantly, whether the elites are deeply literate.

I don't know about you, but when I look at the popular media and at political leaders, they seem highly illiterate compared to those from just a century ago. Even the "literate elite" media, e.g. The New Yorker, has dropped in quality from a few decades ago. Just read some old issues to see what I mean.

Regardless, this article is hardly the first or only study of this problem. Allan Bloom wrote The Closing of the American Mind in 1987. Harold Bloom and John Simon wrote a few books on the topic.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Closing_of_the_American_Mi...

Re:The Erosion of Deep Literacy by giovannibonetti on Saturday December 05, 2020 @10:11AM (#25315082)
Journalism was a very coveted field 50 years ago. Lots of bright people wanted to work there. Nowadays there are many interesting and rewarding jobs for people with good education, and the news industry is losing resources to social networks and online classified sites.

A similar analysis can be applied to explain the decline in the quality of school teachers. Women used to have very few work opportunities in the past, and many of the brightest ones would end up teaching. That's not the case anymore, there are many more rewarding paths nowadays, like getting a law degree.

So, please don't assume the quality of journalism has dropped because the literacy level of society has fallen.

Re:The Erosion of Deep Literacy by paganel on Saturday December 05, 2020 @10:19AM (#25315154)
> The New Yorker, has dropped in quality from a few decades ago. Just read some old issues to see what I mean.

Heck, I remember reading a cycling news article from the sports newspaper L'Equipe citing Villon about 10 years ago (when that newspaper still was a proper one, i.e. big-format), judging by what most French people say on /r/soccer when it comes to L'Equipe that level of literacy has not been maintained.

Re:The Erosion of Deep Literacy by nine_k on Sunday December 06, 2020 @01:26AM (#25321585)
I suspect that quoting Villon in France is like quoting Shakespeare in England, or Pushkin in Russia, or Goethe in Germany, etc. It's likely something you've read (and maybe learned by heart) at school.
Re:The Erosion of Deep Literacy by Poc on Sunday December 06, 2020 @04:45AM (#25322360)
Not really, maybe it was the case 50 years ago (I don't know). Now I'd say the authors that are the most well known in France are Victor Hugo, Molière (we say that french is Molière's tongue), Voltaire and La Fontaine (every student has to learn some of his fable), maybe Baudelaire.

But then again, even tho most french people heard/learned about them, few could quote one of those author.

As for an equivalent of Shakespeare, Pushkin, Goethe or Dante, we don't have any author stamped "best French author", it's a matter of personal opinion I guess. I'd say maybe Proust, but not a lot of people read him. (There is a saying that half the people who say they read Proust, did not).

Re:The Erosion of Deep Literacy by DubiousPusher on Saturday December 05, 2020 @11:45AM (#25315857)
> The issue isn't whether there are abundant "literate" resources (podcasts, in your example)

It was exactly my point that this is not a good argument. But rather that if one wishes to indulge in argument by anecdote, they can find ample evidence for the opposing view of this article.

> I don't know about you, but when I look at the popular media and at political leaders, they seem highly illiterate compared to those from just a century ago

Was Chester A Arthur "deeply literate"? William McKinley? Taft? Harding? Hoover? I suppose I know Teddy Roosevelt was having read his biography but all this again is anecdote.

> Even the "literate elite" media, e.g. The New Yorker, has dropped in quality from a few decades ago.

You'll forgive me if I find a subjective evaluation with a sample size of one unconvincing.

> Regardless, this article is hardly the first or only study of this problem.

Yes most writings about the subject are the same kind of anecdotal grumblings free of concrete evidence. Frankly, as is just about every argument Bloom ever made.

I'm willing to accept the author's conclusion. And honestly I don't really care whether it is true or the opposite is. But if an author wishes for me to carry around their belief as part of my concept of the world they have to do better than this.

Re:The Erosion of Deep Literacy by kiba on Saturday December 05, 2020 @05:16AM (#25313314)
So, it 'seems'. Is there a systematic study measuring the 'literacy' quality of thoughts over time in media?
Re:The Erosion of Deep Literacy by keiferski on Saturday December 05, 2020 @05:19AM (#25313330)
The article itself is about such studies in relation to the brain. A simple google search brings dozens of related results.

https://all4ed.org/articles/a-decade-of-decline-survey-finds...

https://theweek.com/articles/875253/unsurprising-decline-chi...

https://www.edweek.org/ew/articles/1996/05/15/34roch.h15.htm...

https://ivyreads.com/blog/academic-literacy-is-declining

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/247760981_Literacy_...

https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/30/us/reading-scores-nationa...

Furthermore, if your only metric of determining truth is a social science study, I think you're perhaps missing the forest for the trees.

Re:The Erosion of Deep Literacy by LudwigNagasena on Saturday December 05, 2020 @10:50AM (#25315392)
A member of a democratic society, the media and the elites are all different groups and their “deep literacy” may or may not correlate. To me the decline of perceived “literacy” among the elites seems like a direct effect of democratization and doesn’t represent any change of the distribution of “deep literacy” in the whole population.
Re:The Erosion of Deep Literacy by DubiousPusher on Saturday December 05, 2020 @11:56AM (#25316019)
Exactly. Most polticial elites go to the same snazzy colleges as their forebearers where they read Homer and Thucydides. One of the big differences is the kind of public image politicians want to project.

Even still, a lot of this is just our perception. We don't dwell on the history of pugilists that slept in meat lockers or boys sloshing their father's pale of beer as the retrieve it up the street or the thousands of petty riots or the vulgar theater which was always popular. We ignore the masses and read exclusively of the elites or again of the most organized and well written of non-elites.

Yet we must live our present lives without the many professors and researchers having filtered life for us already. So it is likely we see a fairer sampling of common ideas.

Re:The Erosion of Deep Literacy by bem94 on Saturday December 05, 2020 @07:00AM (#25313922)
> This article makes far reaching societal claims with essentially no evidence. The evidence presented is in the form of "feelings" of various writers concerned of their own decline in literaryfocus.

From quite far down in the article, under "Concrete Thinking":

> As it is, we now have greater levels of at least superficial participation in political discourse, if not in politics itself, thanks in part to social-media technologies. Vast numbers of people contribute scantily supported opinions about things they don't really understand, validating the old saw that a little bit of knowledge can be a dangerous thing.

Re:The Erosion of Deep Literacy by DubiousPusher on Saturday December 05, 2020 @03:09PM (#25317833)
You'll have to forgive me but I can still remember when millions of people listened to, called into and cranked each other up on late night radio. The existence of a conspiracy touting ignor-mob-us is hardly concrete evidence of informational decline.

It is possible that social media has intensified this problem. Perhaps more cranks can crank harder together now than before or perhaps not. But "just look at all the people on Facebook" isn't material comparative evidence.

Re:The Erosion of Deep Literacy by wirrbel on Saturday December 05, 2020 @04:47AM (#25313166)
Key bias is that when you read old stuff and people seem to be well read it appears that way also because canons have shifted so it appears as if they read „more than the literature canon“
Re:The Erosion of Deep Literacy by karaterobot on Saturday December 05, 2020 @04:40PM (#25318671)
You're focused on reading as a way of ingesting ideas and culture. The author focused most of his article on the process of reading, and its long term neurological and physiological effects on the reader. In other words, he's not so much saying that people don't know enough, it's that they've lost the ability to focus for long periods of time. It's an attention deficit argument, not an illiteracy argument.

(I think the article is poorly argued and doesn't support itself well; I also think it's probably observing something that is worth continued study)

Re:The Erosion of Deep Literacy by 314 on Saturday December 05, 2020 @07:13AM (#25313976)
Your ability to distill and refute the points in the article seem to be a result of deep literacy. Is this itself not the thrust of his main thesis?
Re:The Erosion of Deep Literacy by DubiousPusher on Saturday December 05, 2020 @03:17PM (#25317900)
Literature is beautiful and deep and fascinating. But it is also dangerous in its power to convey credibility where it may not be due. It is very easy to weave oneself into a net with reason and bind the net fast with literary pomp. How unassailable is my argument once I quote Voltaire!
Re:The Erosion of Deep Literacy by 314 on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @03:43AM (#25356614)
Which implies that somebody responding to you in an argument would also need deep literacy to be able to dismiss such claims. But there is no argument that would progress better if one of the participants was less literate. Which does back up the original claim in the article...