News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Down Here, They Sometimes Call It 'Boy' by glangdale on Saturday December 05, 2020 @02:17AM (#25312550)
> There are almost always deep-rooted issues that the addiction hides

William S Burroughs wrote, at the end of "The Naked Lunch":

"Statistically, the people who become addicted to morphine are those who have access to it: doctors, nurses, anyone in contact with black market sources. In Persia, where opium is sold without control in opium shops, 70 per cent of the adult population is addicted. So we should psychoanalyze several million Persians to find out what deep conflicts and anxieties have driven them to the use of opium? I think not."

Similarly, historical opium addiction in China was largely a function of supply.

I think there's a bit from column A, a bit from column B, and WSB's scoffing at the idea of "psychoanalyzing Persians" does seem a bit... dated (what a concept, that a large number of people might have anxieties and deep conflicts). And I whole-heartedly agree with you about the "health problem not a crime" issue.

However, I often think about that remark of WSB's in connection with some of the more radical ideas about legalization (as opposed to decriminalization/depenalization).

Re:Down Here, They Sometimes Call It 'Boy' by saiya-jin on Saturday December 05, 2020 @04:12AM (#25313004)
Alcoholism was extremely common in the past from where I come from. High society acceptance as long as the person didn't wreak too much havoc. It has been idolized in folklore songs, books and stories for children. Just part of the life. Kids drank sometimes too.

Fast forward today - access to alcohol is even better (apart from minors). Yet society doesn't spiral into alcoholic madness apart form few fringe individuals. Maybe education about the inevitable addiction is better? Or people are smarter than peasants 200 years ago? Or whole cultural mindset about getting wasted as part of being social in nearest pub shifted.

Re:Down Here, They Sometimes Call It 'Boy' by glangdale on Saturday December 05, 2020 @05:41PM (#25319125)
I'd hazard a guess that alcohol is a lot less addictive than heroin, although full-blown alcoholism and withdrawal is no joke.

I think we also have a lot of customs around alcohol to mitigate the level and constancy of drinking required to get addicted. Lots of jokes about "it's 5pm somewhere" or "the sun is over the yard arm", "no drinking on a school night", etc. I think there are generally enough taboos around day drinking or being constantly drunk that most people are nudged away from veering into physical addiction.

Re:Down Here, They Sometimes Call It 'Boy' by jjeaff on Saturday December 05, 2020 @04:26AM (#25313067)
Or maybe alcohol isn't quite as addictive and destructive as heroine and other opiates?
Re:Down Here, They Sometimes Call It 'Boy' by inglor_cz on Saturday December 05, 2020 @08:53AM (#25314567)
That probably depends on the target population as well.

Alcohol seems to be very destructive in Native American communities.

Re:Down Here, They Sometimes Call It 'Boy' by rukuu001 on Saturday December 05, 2020 @02:31PM (#25317548)
I think it’s very true that availability and norms will have a lot to do with drug use, and heroin often doesn’t give a second chance to people who are experimenting.

However the with regard to the idea of ‘deep seated issues’ affecting addiction, I believe this is also true.

We have communities here that provide the opportunity for perfect control of substances - they’re remote and access to them is strictly controlled.

There was widespread alcohol addiction in these places. So alcohol was banned, and these places became ‘dry’ communities.

Lacking alcohol, the people turned to inhaling petrol fumes, which created a large social problem.

Eventually, an ‘un-sniffable’ petrol was created to solve this problem. Then the people turned to paint and glue.

It’s recognized that the people in those communities have suffered a deep, inter-generational trauma, which is what drives people to seek ‘numbing’ relief from substances.

However, it’s the belief that reducing availability of substances will solve substance abuse that’s kept the fundamental problems these people have, from being addressed.

Re:Down Here, They Sometimes Call It 'Boy' by glangdale on Saturday December 05, 2020 @05:51PM (#25319195)
I think you're taking the wrong point away, which is that the causal implication here runs from "wide availability of a substance -> addiction to that substance".

It doesn't say anything about whether a traumatized group will or won't take to substances; it just denies that all addiction is the result of trauma.

The other open question here - I assume you're referring to remote Indigenous communities in Australia - is whether people use substances strictly out of trauma or also out of boredom. The degree to which Indigenous lives are rendered both traumatic but also incredibly boring is shocking. If you've gotten a low quality education, don't have a job and your traditional way of life is no longer viable (it's quite likely you haven't been taught it), how are you going to pass the time?

Re:Down Here, They Sometimes Call It 'Boy' by monoideism on Saturday December 05, 2020 @04:27PM (#25318543)
> It’s recognized that the people in those communities have suffered a deep, inter-generational trauma,

Really? What about the Jewish people, who have been subjected to extremely high levels of inter-generational trauma. Yet they don't fall prey to particularly high levels of alcoholism or drug addiction.

Sure, current poverty can predispose some to addiction, but the idea of "inter-generational trauma" being a massive risk factor is unproven, to say the least.