News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by jsprinkles on Monday May 09, 2011 @06:44PM (#2530509)
On an otherwise empty page? Yes, it is extremely likely when combined with the payload delay. If you manage to make a single tab commit that much memory as a delta without Flash (remember, 13 MB to > 400 MB) please screenshot about:memory and get back to me.

The scroll bars on the tab are revealing, too. I may be guessing but it is an educated guess. Additionally, there were multiple claims so I would not call that specific data point a basis for a claim, singular.

Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by premchai21 on Monday May 09, 2011 @07:32PM (#2530626)
(Note that I haven't been able to see the original video so far, so add salt to taste.)

> If you manage to make a single tab commit that much memory as a delta without Flash (remember, 13 MB to > 400 MB) please screenshot about:memory and get back to me.

I can understand this as a weak prediction, but it certainly doesn't work as a strong one. I can trivially make a tab use over a gigabyte of memory in recent Chromium by creating a gazillion nested objects in JavaScript. (I just did, in fact. If you really want the screenshot and/or source, say so and I'll post it somewhere.) Absent some default limit in V8 that I haven't encountered, I could presumably make it use unbounded memory. I can also create apparently-unbounded latency in a single tab's UI this way, by chewing up CPU in blocking JavaScript code, though this will eventually trigger the “page seems unresponsive” dialog box.

I would also tend to expect an exploit to potentially abuse the JavaScript engine by straining its limits, including things like pouring a large number of identical objects onto the heap to fill memory with exploitable patterns.

Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by yan on Monday May 09, 2011 @07:33PM (#2530629)
No, it's not extremely likely. Given that most browser exploits utilize some sort of a heap spray, a growing memory usage is almost standard pattern for a browser vuln.
Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by jsprinkles on Monday May 09, 2011 @07:43PM (#2530648)
The delay? The scroll bars?

There is evidence that this is Flash. However, since everyone seems to want to attack individual parts of that evidence without applying Occam's Razor, I concede it could be something other than Flash. It could be Java, too. It could be a "standard browser exploit" too, whatever that is. Could be cosmic rays too.

The tendency to look for ways to prove me wrong with an alternate theory (which yours is) as opposed to acknowledging that multiple theories are possible with zero evidence aggravates me among technical people. In the absence of a disclosure we are both right.

Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by yan on Monday May 09, 2011 @07:53PM (#2530673)
You seem to only want to receive an answer that starts with "You bring up credible evidence, but maybe there's an alternate scenario playing out here, for which I believe the following holds true..." Now I can do that, but since we're all speculating, this is implied. No one is saying you're dead wrong, we're just posting alternate hypothesis and you're taking this very personally.

Let's apply Occam's razor: a) There is no reason why Flash (or another plugin) needs to take up a large amount of space on the page. If I were to write a flash exploit, it'd be a 1x1 object with whatever ActionScript that triggers the vulnerability, no need for a large area. b) VUPEN is a bunch of extremely talented folks and I believe they have little to gain by posting a fabricated exploit video. c) The delay can also be caused by a rather advanced heap-grooming technique, it can be JS garbage collection invoked many times, it can literally be them trying the payload numerous times. Implying it's probably flash is just as speculative as we're being.

Relax man, no one's disagreeing with you to be an asshole, no one's trying to argue with you, we're all just speculating.

Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by jsprinkles on Monday May 09, 2011 @08:01PM (#2530697)
No, I do not want to receive an answer. That would imply that I asked a question in my OP.
Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by sswam on Monday May 09, 2011 @07:49PM (#2530662)
so google can fix it for 99% cases with ulimit or similar windows thing. problem solved
Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by jrockway on Monday May 09, 2011 @07:50PM (#2530665)
No, Google can fix by not letting programs downloaded from the Internet write to arbitrary memory locations.

Actually, you can fix it, too: chromium is open source.

Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by jsprinkles on Monday May 09, 2011 @07:54PM (#2530675)
Actually, you can fix it, too: chromium is open source.

Good to see this tired claim getting its play in this thread. I wondered how long it would be until it showed up. I think everyone who says "go fix it, it's open-source" should instead be required to come back with a diff within 24 hours.

Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by jrockway on Monday May 09, 2011 @08:02PM (#2530698)
People are quick to demand bug fixes or better security, but they never seem interested in actually doing the work.

I don't use Chrome or Windows, so I have almost negative personal interest in this story. However, some people probably do use Chrome and Windows, and those people's demands should be tempered by reality. If they didn't find this bug, why did they expect Google to?

I think everyone who says "go fix it, it's open-source" should instead be required to come back with a diff within 24 hours.

I think everyone should be required to give me a pony.

Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by jsprinkles on Monday May 09, 2011 @08:05PM (#2530705)
The person you replied to did not demand anything but instead theorized about a way to fix it.

I love how you assert that literally anybody could check out Chromium and fix the sandbox, a sensitive security-essential part of the browser, with very little effort required to appreciate the source and all of the moving parts.

Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by jrockway on Monday May 09, 2011 @08:49PM (#2530800)
I love how you assert that literally everybody is too dumb to understand computer programs that they use.
Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by jsprinkles on Monday May 09, 2011 @08:58PM (#2530813)
Not dumb, there's just a lot of skills assumed to work on the security components of a modern Web browser. I would never claim that I could turn around and fix this bug as an outside developer. Words in my mouth.
Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by jrockway on Monday May 09, 2011 @09:03PM (#2530829)
In my opinion, this is one step away from sacrificing a virgin to make it rain. We should control our own software destiny and not just hope other people will do it for us.
Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by evilduck on Monday May 09, 2011 @10:13PM (#2530985)
Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by jrockway on Monday May 09, 2011 @11:31PM (#2531175)
Please avoid introducing classic flamewar topics unless you have something genuinely new to say about them.
Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by zmmmmm on Monday May 09, 2011 @07:17PM (#2530591)
It just sounds to me like they are exploiting a size overflow in some kind of content - a 400MB image, video, sound, 400MB of self expanding Javascript ... I'm not sure how you can conclude only flash can take such memory.
Re:Google Chrome Hacked? by nl on Monday May 09, 2011 @08:15PM (#2530725)
* If you manage to make a single tab commit that much memory as a delta without Flash*

Not 100% sure, and I haven't tried it, but I suspect it would be possible using this bug: http://code.google.com/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=25047