Putting stable coin issuers under banking regulations would have obvious benefits for the public in terms of trustworthiness. It would even have benefits for the no-coin public by reducing systemic risk. And it would have benefits for stable coin issuers and crypto exchanges by making it easier for them to establish conventional banking connections for their customers — right now, the on/offramps for many of exchanges seem to look dangerously close to money laundering in many cases.
For instance, the largest stablecoin right now, Tether:
* Has issued $16B in new currency in 2020 alone, after starting the year with $4B total: https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/tether/
* Has never been independently audited, and the size, composition, and location of its reserves is not known.
* Has ownership with significant overlap with Bitfinex, one of the larger Cryptocurrency exchanges, and seems to have commingled funds with them to some extent.
This is really a situation that ought to be audited sooner rather than later. And, whether that audit reveals massive fraud or an upstanding, misunderstood business, the cryptocurrency community should welcome such transparency.
Furthermore, while the entity you've given the dollars to promises you can ask for them back (plus/minus any transfers you've arranged with others) at any point, there's no guarantee that they have a bag of dollar bills in a hole in the ground somewhere, and in fact they probably don't: they're almost certainly doing something with the dollar bills to make themselves money, in a way where they preserve enough liquidity to return dollars for the people who ask for them, but not all at once.
The only difference is the technical form of the variable associated with your account. The API and the social purpose is the same.
Being able to say that your coins are functionally identical to USD, FDIC insured and directly spendable P2P-ish adds a lot of legitimacy.
We can have a looong discussion about the regulations that surround banks but that doesn't change whether these entities are banks.