News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US ends era of emotional support animals on planes by onetimemanytime on Thursday December 03, 2020 @01:48PM (#25292818)
not to be jerk or anything, but if I said that a cow or an elephant is the only thing that soothes me so accommodate them in a plane?

How many other people should be inconvenienced by my issues?

Re:US ends era of emotional support animals on planes by happytoexplain on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:07PM (#25293067)
None, since it would probably be deemed infeasible. I think the tendency of engineers to extrapolate "rules" to extreme cases creates a lot of noise. Rules in law, business, and society are not the same as rules in engineering - they allow for subjectivity.
Re:US ends era of emotional support animals on planes by happytoexplain on Friday December 04, 2020 @09:27AM (#25302511)
I don't understand the point you're making.

A. Your examples are of animals disallowed - not allowed.

B. Those animals are obviously much more feasible, physically.

C. Regardless of how feasible they are, I simply gave a reasonable answer to the question - I didn't imply that all human systems have that same answer.

You should explain your thoughts, instead of only posting links with no context.

Re:US ends era of emotional support animals on planes by raztogt21 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:37PM (#25293528)
"Rules in law, business, and society are not the same as rules in engineering - they allow for subjectivity." Thanks for sharing this thought.
Re:US ends era of emotional support animals on planes by DanBC on Thursday December 03, 2020 @01:55PM (#25292912)
Adjustments for disabled people need to be "reasonable".

It's reasonable for a blind person to take their guide dog on a plane. It's reasonable for someone with mental illness to take their well trained support animal on the plane.

It's unreasonable for someone who's struggling a bit to take their pet cow on a plane.

Re:US ends era of emotional support animals on planes by lotsofpulp on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:18PM (#25294161)
It's also reasonable to not want to want you or your family sat near a pitbull or other known aggressive breed. Everyone tells me their dog is well behaved and friendly, but I've had to scare dogs away from my kids more than once. My mom has been chased walking around her neighborhood by people violating leash laws. Every time, everyone says their dogs are well trained or well behaved.
Re:US ends era of emotional support animals on planes by TulliusCicero on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:58PM (#25293844)
Who decides what's reasonable, though?

The whole thing is a big grey area. The rules should be explicit.

Re:US ends era of emotional support animals on planes by llbeansandrice on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:00PM (#25293890)
> Who decides what's reasonable, though?

The court system. I say something is reasonable, you do not and don't allow me on a flight so I take you to court over it and the court decides.

Re:US ends era of emotional support animals on planes by TulliusCicero on Thursday December 03, 2020 @04:14PM (#25295061)
That's not good. The courts should only have to get involved in exceptional scenarios. The law itself should be more clear.
Re:US ends era of emotional support animals on planes by llbeansandrice on Thursday December 03, 2020 @04:29PM (#25295301)
I suppose that's your opinion but that's just not how the law works and in many cases the subjectivity is a feature not a bug.

It might be a common sense thing to say that no one would ever want or have need to use a horse as a service animal, but there are miniature horses that are service animals.

Re:US ends era of emotional support animals on planes by TulliusCicero on Thursday December 03, 2020 @09:20PM (#25298185)
It's not uncommon for judges to complain about laws being excessively vague, so no, it's not just my opinion.

Also IIRC miniature horses being service animals is explicitly part of the law, so I'm not sure why you're using that as an example.

Re:US ends era of emotional support animals on planes by bluGill on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:04PM (#25293944)
the problem with explicit is you will forget about some corner case.
Re:US ends era of emotional support animals on planes by maxk42 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:55PM (#25293808)
Well the laws here are really stupid. ESAs are not covered under federal law. But service animals are. However - there is no accreditation program for service animals, so you cannot ask for proof that an animal is a service animal. You are also not allowed to ask a person what their disability is or demand they demonstrate some sort of proof of either disability or specialized training in their animal. So essentially, anyone can still claim any animal is a service animal and the airlines have to accommodate them. The ESA designation is NOT a service animal (although a service animal can also be an ESA). So this is something the airlines could easily disallow. I'm afraid we haven't seen the last of people abusing the system for their own convenience, however.
Re:US ends era of emotional support animals on planes by crazcarl on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:05PM (#25293959)
This is incorrect per the article. It clearly states "Wednesday's rule change by the US Department of Transportation now says only dogs qualify as service animals."

So no, the airlines don't have to accept someone's service animal that isn't a dog.

Re:US ends era of emotional support animals on planes by maxk42 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @07:15PM (#25297379)
I didn't say they did.
Re:US ends era of emotional support animals on planes by s1artibartfast on Thursday December 03, 2020 @01:52PM (#25292862)
None, now that the rules have been clarified to disallow your cow or elephant.
Re:US ends era of emotional support animals on planes by devteambravo on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:02PM (#25292994)
So let's just make assumptions then. Disabled people should have a case prepared, and always be ready to argue it in front of people. Upon challenge, by people "inconvenienced" by your accommodations, you should be able to spend 2 minutes showcasing your disability, how it came to be, and plead for said accommodations. Maybe you could edit that "not to be a jerk" bit to "I'm a jerk, hence:".
Re:US ends era of emotional support animals on planes by claytongulick on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:25PM (#25293353)
When "inconvenienced" means a trip to the ER or landing a plane because you have severe allergies (like me) then the definition of who is being a jerk in the "emotional support animal" situation is a big more vague, no?
Re:US ends era of emotional support animals on planes by dash2 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:52PM (#25293767)
To be clear about this, your argument is that a disabled person should be able to say "I need an elephant on this plane" without having to explain why? Also, disagreeing with this point of view makes someone a jerk? :-)
Re:US ends era of emotional support animals on planes by MereInterest on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:58PM (#25293845)
Please read up on the term "Invisible Disabilities". Not every disability is obvious, not every disability is immediately provable to satisfy an adhoc request, and not every disability has immediate effects. Your suggestion would lead to people being further marginalized, if every person feels that they can barge in for 2 minutes each. Add up more and more people each stealing away 2 minutes, and that is quite a lot of time.

How would that even work, too? If a random person decides that somebody's disability doesn't exist, do they then just barge in even more than usual. "I decided that your coeliac disease didn't exist, so I used wheat as a thickener. Your fault for not explaining it better."

Re:US ends era of emotional support animals on planes by TulliusCicero on Thursday December 03, 2020 @02:59PM (#25293872)
This is a bit of a whoosh moment, as the person you're replying to is actually on the same side as you.
Re:US ends era of emotional support animals on planes by devteambravo on Thursday December 03, 2020 @05:42PM (#25296321)
My point exactly. Btw, I'm one of those invisibly disabled people you mention. "Luckily", I also have massive scarring all over, so I don't have to explain myself to people as much.
Re:US ends era of emotional support animals on planes by MereInterest on Thursday December 03, 2020 @06:21PM (#25296819)
Thank you, and sorry for missing the sarcasm in your post. I had interpreted your post as giving a suggestion, rather than as being the inevitable and absurd conclusion of the parent's reasoning.