Re:The Pirate Bay: “The Battle of Internets is About to Begin”
by vixen99 on Monday May 09, 2011 @01:32PM
(#2529482)
This is symptomatic of the whole EU enterprise. You might ask how it is that a totally non-elected person like Baroness Ashton, the so-called High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy of the European Union and Vice President of the EU (I repeat, no one elected her bar a coterie of the elite in the EU) can call for the EU to be given a seat on the UN Security Council. By the way, the president of the EU is unelected as well. Oh, and the EU finances have not been passed by the auditors in 13 years.
I apologize for this off-topic comment but a little background for non-EU folk is useful in considering this latest EU nonsense regarding the internet.
Re:The Pirate Bay: “The Battle of Internets is About to Begin”
by fauigerzigerk on Monday May 09, 2011 @06:24PM
(#2530459)
Civil servants, government ministers and heads of state in many if not most democratic countries are not elected directly by the people. There's nothing special about the EU in that regard.
Re:The Pirate Bay: “The Battle of Internets is About to Begin”
by omouse on Monday May 09, 2011 @08:17PM
(#2530726)
It's a symptom of government to reduce one's freedom and human rights.
Re:The Pirate Bay: “The Battle of Internets is About to Begin”
by calpaterson on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @06:22AM
(#2531986)
Haha! Complaining that no one elected Baroness Ashton is like saying that no one elected Georgy Zhukov - almost no one in the EU is elected.
Re:The Pirate Bay: “The Battle of Internets is About to Begin”
by tomjen3 on Monday May 09, 2011 @11:17AM
(#2528952)
They don't need legitimacy - they have guns.
Fortunately we have compilers and computers so the fight isn't going to be fair.
Re:The Pirate Bay: “The Battle of Internets is About to Begin”
by anonymoushn on Monday May 09, 2011 @11:40AM
(#2529030)
Legitimacy is actually made out of guns.
Re:The Pirate Bay: “The Battle of Internets is About to Begin”
by tomjen3 on Monday May 09, 2011 @12:00PM
(#2529115)
No it is made out of consent of the ruled.
The moment they loose consent they become the oppressors.
Re:The Pirate Bay: “The Battle of Internets is About to Begin”
by Deestan on Monday May 09, 2011 @12:18PM
(#2529207)
Being oppressive doesn't remove your legitimacy.
As long as you can hold on to being the government (guns!), you make the laws and are by definition legitimacy itself.
Re:The Pirate Bay: “The Battle of Internets is About to Begin”
by r00fus on Monday May 09, 2011 @01:29PM
(#2529469)
Don't confuse power and legitimacy.
This is one of the major reasons why India isn't ruled by the British now.
British had power, Gandhi and the peaceful revolutionists had legitimacy... guns can only project so much power.
Re:The Pirate Bay: “The Battle of Internets is About to Begin”
by mvalle on Monday May 09, 2011 @01:54PM
(#2529547)
Guns are the only form of power. Sometimes you just don't have enough guns.
Re:The Pirate Bay: “The Battle of Internets is About to Begin”
by getsat on Monday May 09, 2011 @05:59PM
(#2530376)
One could argue that money is more powerful than firearms. How much power and influence do corporations wield? I don't see many CEOs packing heat.
Re:The Pirate Bay: “The Battle of Internets is About to Begin”
by danenania on Monday May 09, 2011 @09:06PM
(#2530836)
They can influence those who do.
Re:The Pirate Bay: “The Battle of Internets is About to Begin”
by mvalle on Sunday May 15, 2011 @06:33AM
(#2549721)
Case in point: Gaddafi
Re:The Pirate Bay: “The Battle of Internets is About to Begin”
by calpaterson on Monday May 09, 2011 @07:45PM
(#2530653)
You might say that morally it should come from consent, but descriptively, legitimacy comes from having a monopoly on force and not being totally, utterly hated.
Re:The Pirate Bay: “The Battle of Internets is About to Begin”
by getsat on Monday May 09, 2011 @04:08PM
(#2530026)
Legitimacy comes from:
Democracy, e.g., election as described by customs or laws
Tradition, e.g., a monarch's son becoming the next monarch
Charisma, e.g., a charismatic leader such as a tribe leader, dictators like Hitler, etc.
The military junta currently running Burma/Myanmar has a lot of guns, but it is not legitimate.
Re:The Pirate Bay: “The Battle of Internets is About to Begin”
by mariuskempe on Monday May 09, 2011 @12:08PM
(#2529163)
Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahaahahahahahahahahahahahahaha legendary.
Re:The Pirate Bay: “The Battle of Internets is About to Begin”
by teamonkey on Monday May 09, 2011 @11:51AM
(#2529081)
They can talk about whatever they like, it doesn't mean it will pass. This working group has no authority on their own.
Re:The Pirate Bay: “The Battle of Internets is About to Begin”
by lutorm on Monday May 09, 2011 @01:10PM
(#2529407)
Do I detect a small amount of sarcasm about the democratic structure of the EU?
Re:The Pirate Bay: “The Battle of Internets is About to Begin”
by fauigerzigerk on Monday May 09, 2011 @06:47PM
(#2530513)
The democratic legitimacy of that working group derives from the democratic legitimacy of the governments that send their representatives. I'm not happy with these proposals at all, but it's not exactly unusual that such proposals are being worked on by civil servants and ministers.
How can some small EU working group even dare to discuss my human rights in a secret meeting without any democratic legitimacy?