Can you imagine the carnage and 'natural herd immunity' of 5 years of all of the holidays everyone ignoring the quarantines would give us?
If the virus is life-threatening (and I believe it is) then there is a natural disincentive to not taking necessary precautions and individuals will act accordingly, creating a positive systemic outcome. This is the basis of liberal democracy, we trust our citizens with freedom and this in turn results in better outcomes (esp innovation).
Freedom isn’t something we do just because we’re “selfish” or it’s a luxury, it’s literally a better system.
I would imply that you should have payed more attention in civics, thus insulting your intelligence but I prefer civil and respectful discourse. Ideas matter.
This pandemic clearly showed that telling people to "just use your common sense" in an once-in-a-lifetime crisis leads to disaster. Hardly surprising, when you think about it - we never tell employers/employees to "just use your common sense whether a particular construction job is dangerous," in fact we have elaborate rules to decide exactly what is dangerous, and a whole government department to enforce it, so why would a novel infectious disease that nobody has any hands-on experience any different?
People work construction jobs voluntarily. Voluntary is good. Let’s live in a voluntary collaboration-oriented society. We did, once.
This isn’t about individuals being “forced” to take the vaccine. policy is being made on a systemic level, either promote a traditionally undertested vaccine to the public, without their ability to seek damages, or restrict their rights to voluntarily gather and do business
But that's not what you want either it seems.
The existence of a vaccine should absolutely have no effect on anyone’s ability to do business with anyone else. That should be their decision to make. My life has been ruined from this. I’m blown away that I have to state this in a liberal democracy.
Edit: Though it seems it's legal sometimes to force people to vaccinate: https://khn.org/morning-breakout/a-court-case-from-the-early...
The population never really had the freedom to run around and spread diseases harming people.
> The population never really had the freedom to run around and spread diseases harming people.
I don't know what you mean exactly. People have generally enjoyed the freedom to roam without being subject to liability or investigation as to whether they might be spreading an illness. Flying or going to the grocery store with a bad cough and a fever was considered poor etiquette but not a matter for legal sanction. The worst that would happen was not being allowed to send your kids to public school.
From e.g.: https://www.healthaffairs.org/do/10.1377/hblog20200508.76910... on the 1918 pandemic (article is from May 2020)
"Most famously, San Francisco, California, along with other Western cities such as Seattle, Washington, Juneau, Alaska, and Phoenix, Arizona, passed laws requiring masks in public. Violators could be ticketed, fined, and imprisoned."
You'll find a few instances of people being fined for measles-related stuff: https://abcnews.go.com/Health/york-city-issues-fines-1000-pe...
https://www.jsonline.com/story/communities/west/news/brookfi...
If you search for quarantine break-related laws, you'll e.g. find this 2005 CA law: https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/q-1.1/page-7.html
This Australian law on grievous bodily harm contains, "does any act that is likely to result in a person having a serious disease": https://www.slp.wa.gov.au/statutes/swans.nsf/650321a87e813bb...
Thus I think it's okay to tell people that they didn't have this freedom they apparently believed they had.