News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On Casuistry by pdonis on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @10:14AM (#25277033)
> I think it's more of an acknowledgment that Gödel's incompleteness theorem applies to any system of reasoning or knowledge

Godel's theorem is a limitation on any system of formal rules, but it's not the limitation I'm talking about.

> Even known true statements can't be proved all the way down --- at some point they have to rest on axioms that are assumed (or taken on faith).

This is a different limitation from Godel's theorem, but it's also not quite the limitation I'm talking about (though I think it's related to it--see below).

> I believe there is an objectively true worldview upon which objective moral values and duties rest

This is the limitation I'm talking about. Even if you have an objectively true view of the world, moral values and duties aren't just about the way the world is; they're about the way humans want the world to be. And human wants are subjective; if you and I disagree about how we want the world to be, there is no objective way to resolve our disagreement.

There are no comments on this comment yet.