News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alternative notation for exponents, logs and roots? (2011) by Zhyl on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @05:11AM (#25275054)
I think it's worth linking to the 'Notation as a tool of thought' thread from the other day, as it gave me quite a lot to read, watch and think about [0].

It also reminds me of Graphical Linear Algebra [1] which I occasionally see mentioned here. And, as included in my comment in that thread, the notion of using Tau as the circle constant in equations [2].

Notation is a weird topic to tackle. Like with new technologies or languages on HN, there seem to be those who get [a new notation when it is proposed] and evangelise it, and those who see it as pointless and vocally dismiss it. Posts like the article where you're weighing up and exploring benefits and limitations of notation seem rare - and even those that do exist seem to be pitching for their new notation to be a global replacement rather than as a pedagogical or epistemological tool.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25249563

[1] https://graphicallinearalgebra.net/about/

[2] https://tauday.com

Re:Alternative notation for exponents, logs and roots? (2011) by sriku on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @07:27AM (#25275734)
While a notation for this case makes for an interesting discussion (which the post is), the "blast radius" of this situation is so small that (to me) it wouldn't be worth adopting any of the proposals (not saying anyone there pushed them).

For a notation to be worth adoption,its impact must be far reaching. The "graphical linear algebra" makes a good case with a larger blast radius, for example. However even that has nowhere near the impact of, say, Feynman diagrams.

The x^y notation is repurposed elsewhere - ex: power set of a set S is written 2^S .. with no implication that the "logarithm" of the power set to the base 2 is S. Same for matrices raised to a power, where matrices are usually not thought of as a base for doing logarithms. Same for operators in calculus (ex: laplacian .. now that would be confusing to club with a triangle!)

Re:Alternative notation for exponents, logs and roots? (2011) by alanbernstein on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @08:24AM (#25276108)
I'm not sure what you mean by blast radius, but if you were to think about the amount of people learning these concepts - as explained in the SE post here - the order would obviously be the reverse of what you suggest (exponents most important).
Re:Alternative notation for exponents, logs and roots? (2011) by sriku on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @08:39AM (#25276212)
By "blast radius" I meant the impact of the notation beyond the originating case into other areas. I wasn't referring to the number of people it would impact. The notation in the OP doesn't play well with "nearby" areas like powerset and matrices .. which are well served by the conventional exponentiation notation.
Re:Alternative notation for exponents, logs and roots? (2011) by umvi on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @09:45AM (#25276743)
Speaking of Feynman, I remember when he was in high school he invented his own notation[0] for sin/cos/tan to use little angular lines, but then the issue he ran into was that nobody could decipher his math notation and he had trouble helping others learn, so he conformed to the sin/cos/tan notation.

[0] https://tex.stackexchange.com/questions/274463/feynman-trig-...

Re:Alternative notation for exponents, logs and roots? (2011) by OscarCunningham on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @12:07PM (#25278507)
> The "graphical linear algebra" makes a good case with a larger blast radius, for example. However even that has nowhere near the impact of, say, Feynman diagrams.

These are sort of the same example! They're both string diagrams (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/String_diagram), just in different monoidal categories.

Re:Alternative notation for exponents, logs and roots? (2011) by WorldMaker on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @03:34PM (#25281194)
It also reminds me of the Calculus itself. It's often considered one of the best outcomes of Newton and Liebniz discovering the Calculus nearly simultaneously and with little to no coordination until after the fact is that as people discussed the results and compared the two efforts what we ultimately ended up with was a lot of Newton's insights and pedagogy, but based more upon Liebniz's notation.

That has long stuck with me that Liebniz developed a better, more generally useful notation as a tool of thought for following mathematicians, but Newton still developed a lot more lasting insights into the Calculus despite a generally more "inferior" notation (though certainly a notation presumably specifically more useful to Newton's own thought processes).

Re:Alternative notation for exponents, logs and roots? (2011) by chrisweekly on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @08:04AM (#25275946)
Kudos for the insightful comment and good links.

Tangent: I first stumbled upon the Tau manifesto several years ago, and though it made sense to me, I couldn't tell whether anyone took it seriously. Still wondering.

Re:Alternative notation for exponents, logs and roots? (2011) by Zhyl on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @08:52AM (#25276306)
I was a Math undergrad when I first read it and I think the main reaction I got from faculty was 'dismissal' and the main reaction I got from peers was 'indifference' and, in one case 'annoyance'.

I think it took root in the pop-math education space [0,1], but overall I think most of the Mathematical world has dismissed it as trivial at best and unnecessarily disruptive at worst.

It's a shame, because I feel that understanding why Tau makes equations and concepts easier for people to grasp and build intuitions around is key to understanding why people generally find maths difficult and frustrating, and can give some guidance on how to bring down that barrier/activation energy.

[0] Vi Hart, Pi is Wrong (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jG7vhMMXagQ)

[1] Numberphile, Pi vs Tau Smackdown (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZPv1UV0rD8U)

Re:Alternative notation for exponents, logs and roots? (2011) by threatofrain on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @09:30AM (#25276611)
People are looking at a bigger delta of improvement than that, IMO, but that also means they only want big commits from big names. The Tau thing really is too trivial, which means it may be outweighed by friction alone.
Re:Alternative notation for exponents, logs and roots? (2011) by Zhyl on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @10:18AM (#25277069)
Yeah, the circle constant is considered 'solved' and has been a well understood concept since... (googles) .. oh wow, 2560 BCE [0], with pi being used as the symbol for the last 400 odd years [1]. It's understandable that there wouldn't be much appetite to tamper with that if there isn't a gosh darned good reason.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pi#History

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pi#Adoption_of_the_symbol_%CF%...

(Interesting to note the original coining of Pi was π/δ for what we now call Pi (circumference over diameter) and π/ρ for what we are calling Tau (circumference over radius).)

Re:Alternative notation for exponents, logs and roots? (2011) by alisonkisk on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @11:05AM (#25277646)
Tau looks too much like Pi.

It should be Rho for Rotation.

Re:Alternative notation for exponents, logs and roots? (2011) by Zhyl on Thursday December 03, 2020 @09:07AM (#25288908)
Thanks, Alison.
Re:Alternative notation for exponents, logs and roots? (2011) by chriswarbo on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @05:26PM (#25282564)
I think there's more basic opportunity for intuition and learning than pi/tau, which is using turns for angles. We tend to use degrees, which is less direct and requires memorisation/familiarity with magic numbers like 30, 45, 60, 90, 180, 720, etc. It takes more work to translate these numbers back and forth into angles (e.g. clock hands or pie charts) compared to twelfth, eighth, sixth, fourth, half, one, two, etc. turns. I think degrees should be left as a historical curiosity, like gradians, rather than the default we reach for in everyday life, from a young age (I can also see them being a nice 'mental maths shortcut', for those who are into such things).

I know many people struggle with fractions, which degrees can avoid (at least, on a surface level), but I don't know whether the highly composite nature of 360 would help, and fractions hinder, outside of classroom-style exercises. For example, 90 + 45 = 135 is easier to calculate than 1/4 + 1/8 = 3/8, but the latter might still be more intuitive as an angle (e.g. if answering with a diagram, or by turning one's body); and for anything more complicated than that I'd still reach for a calculator, even with degrees.

When problems require more sophistication than turns, we can introduce radians like we currently do. At that point tau makes sense as their conversion factor in equations, but it's still an unnecessary complexity when expressing angles; since any nice multiple of tau (or pi) can be divided through to get an even nicer number of turns.

Re:Alternative notation for exponents, logs and roots? (2011) by OscarCunningham on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @12:18PM (#25278662)
It's in practice impossible to change a mathematical convention so deeply embedded as π. So even though a lot of mathematicians 'take it seriously' in the sense of agreeing that τ is the more fundamental concept, none 'take it seriously' in the sense of actually using it in public mathematics.