News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On Casuistry by bilbo0s on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @09:08PM (#25272501)
The unpleasant truth is that if you live in a community whose members are not good people, you won't have good outcomes

Again, the quandary is that if you live in a community whose members are "good" people, you also won't have good outcomes. That's the nature of people. They are not "bad" or "good". They are just humans. Their actions are sometimes "bad", sometimes "good", but rarely are their actions consistently the one or the other. That's just the nature of being human. In fact, it's the entire reason we talk about "justice" in the first place.

Re:On Casuistry by pdonis on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @10:07PM (#25272830)
> if you live in a community whose members are "good" people, you also won't have good outcomes

I disagree. Historically there are plenty of examples of communities that have managed to get along for extended periods with reasonably good outcomes. What we humans don't (yet) have a good handle on is how to protect such communities against invasion from outside--other people outside the communities just won't leave them alone, but insist on trying to make them part of some larger social experiment.

Re:On Casuistry by voldacar on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @09:28PM (#25272626)
There is definitely such a thing as moral virtue or character. Maybe "bad" and "good" are too simplistic but there are definitely more virtuous and less virtuous humans
Re:On Casuistry by pdonis on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @10:03PM (#25272811)
> There is definitely such a thing as moral virtue or character.

Yes, but those are subjective as well; there's no objective test for who is virtuous and who is not. Everyone has to judge that for themselves.