Re:Randall Munroe is learning new things from Google
by bmitc on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @05:42PM
(#25271042)
I don’t think it’s a UI problem. You are presuming the system knows the question it is answering.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Randall Munroe is learning new things from Google
by dwild on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @11:17AM
(#25277804)
Yeah, it's not answering questions, it's giving the best answers which they could find themselves. It doesn't means it's the actual answer, nor that it's to the actual question, that's up to you to confirm.
Google isn't an encyclopedia, it's a search engine. It search inside content and try to find the best content that fit your criteria, it could be from trustworthy source, or not, it could be right or wrong on what you meant. For sure their goal is to give you the closest thing to what you asked, with the best sources, but it's not a guarantee, so it shouldn't be trusted as such.
It's crazy that we all came from the "don't trust Wikipedia" and now some people are arguing that we should be able to trust Google results directly.