Plenty of statistical-AI people themselves hold similar views on that subject, and almost every machine-learning or AI conference has a panel or keynote that expresses dismay at what the field looks like (balkanized, too focused on methods rather than problems, too focused on incremental algorithm tweaks).
For example, Leslie Pack Kaelbling's AAAI-2010 keynote had the thesis that we need to stop focusing on incremental algorithm improvements in tiny sub-areas of AI, tested on implausibly pure toy benchmark problems with a focus on optimality proofs, and start focusing more on putting things together into integrated systems that handle real-world problems, which will probably require more hybrid methods (like statistical-AI + logical-AI). Though she expressed it a bit more diplomatically, with the tone that we're not fulfilling the potential of the field with the current approach, and has actually done some concrete work following her own proposal. (Slides: http://people.csail.mit.edu/lpk/AAAI10LPK.pdf)