News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ditch Nuclear and Save $860M with Grid Flexibility, U.K. ... by boomboomsubban on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @04:54AM (#25263887)
This is a fairly blatant advertisement from Wärtsilä. It clearly states that their goal was to find renewables to be the best option, minimizes the continued reliance on fossil fuels in their plan, and fudges the cost by assuming everything has the same 20 year lifetime.
Re:Ditch Nuclear and Save $860M with Grid Flexibility, U.K. ... by ncmncm on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @05:06AM (#25263937)
That is about the same (or better) level of scruples as nuke advocates invariably exercise. In some places it is the only way to get a fair hearing.

The US federal govt just granted $1.4B to an Oregon company to build nukes for a site in Idaho. That $1.4B could build a hell of a lot of solar and energy storage that would work immediately.

Re:Ditch Nuclear and Save $860M with Grid Flexibility, U.K. ... by boomboomsubban on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @06:16AM (#25264268)
>In some places it is the only way to get a fair hearing.

Intentionally misrepresenting the facts ensures this isn't a fair hearing. Sure the nuclear industry is guilty of it as well, but we still should be skeptical of any "report" that claims the best plan is the one that will make their company millions of dollars.

>That $1.4B could build a hell of a lot of solar and energy storage that would work immediately.

Or it could build a nuclear plant that would generate more energy overall.

Re:Ditch Nuclear and Save $860M with Grid Flexibility, U.K. ... by ncmncm on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @04:37AM (#25274855)
Intentionally misrepresenting the facts is universally observed behavior in all promotion of fission power, as seen even here.

No nuke plant has been built for $1.4B. So, no, that would be just a down payment for a plant that might produce power at great additional cost a decade or more later, if not abandoned first. Solar could begin producing power immediately, during build-out. And at night, from stored energy.

We have decades of actual records on the actual performance of fission power. It stinks. It has been a massive publicly subsidized boondoggle for 70 years. Too much is enough.

Re:Ditch Nuclear and Save $860M with Grid Flexibility, U.K. ... by boomboomsubban on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @12:32PM (#25278819)
I did not think it was necessary to clarify that the amount of money you brought up would not build an entire nuclear power plant. That was not me misrepresenting anything.

I'm always perplexed by the people that claim it is clear that nuclear power is a lost cause. If the evidence is so strong that renewables are the best economic choice, why is this company making up shit to draw people away from nuclear? Why do people resort to disaster scare tactics if nuclear isn't at least competitive on price?

Re:Ditch Nuclear and Save $860M with Grid Flexibility, U.K. ... by ncmncm on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @03:18PM (#25281015)
> I did not think it was necessary to clarify that the amount of money you brought up would not build an entire nuclear power plant.

(No comment.)

> Why do people resort to disaster scare tactics if nuclear isn't at least competitive on price?

Perhaps to counter promoters who habitually resort to deception, as observed even in the august pages of HN?

Re:Ditch Nuclear and Save $860M with Grid Flexibility, U.K. ... by boomboomsubban on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @06:11PM (#25283038)
>Perhaps to counter promoters who habitually resort to deception, as observed even in the august pages of HN?

This "because the other side lies we need to too" excuse is nonsense. If nuclear power is a "massive publicly subsidized boondoggle" then you should be able to show a clear advantage without resorting to deception.

Re:Ditch Nuclear and Save $860M with Grid Flexibility, U.K. ... by ncmncm on Thursday December 03, 2020 @11:56AM (#25291036)
In some circumstances, the facts and truth carry no weight, and outcomes depend on who promises more.

Such circumstances are reliably identified anywhere retail fission power got built.

Re:Ditch Nuclear and Save $860M with Grid Flexibility, U.K. ... by boomboomsubban on Thursday December 03, 2020 @01:24PM (#25292481)
You keep saying things like the deception of the nuclear industry can be "reliably identified" yet you seem unable to provide any support for these claims. You then willingly turn a blind eye to the deception of the renewables industry, and your only attempt to defend this practice is to throw more mud at the nuclear industry.

I just can not understand this position.

Re:Ditch Nuclear and Save $860M with Grid Flexibility, U.K. ... by ncmncm on Friday December 04, 2020 @11:32AM (#25304236)
There is no controversy over the fact that fission plants have always, right from the very first one, been more expensive than mature alternatives, often much more.

Still, nuke plants got built, and still operate. Why? Promoters insisted they would not be more expensive, and would in fact be cheaper, knowing full well (as was revealed later) that they would not.

Thus, the only reason nuke, and lately coal, plants continue operating is corruption. Most recently, details leaked of what happened in Ohio to keep theirs operating, involving $millions in bribes in exchange for $billions in public subsidies.

So this "can not understand" is not convincing. The facts are public for anybody who cares to learn them. Protestations of innocence ring hollow. There is no one left to fool.

Re:Ditch Nuclear and Save $860M with Grid Flexibility, U.K. ... by boomboomsubban on Saturday December 05, 2020 @05:29AM (#25313391)
You are blindly trusting the "facts" one side alleges while claiming the other side does nothing but shamelessly lie to fill their own pockets. That is what I can not understand. Stating there is no controversy in this position is ridiculous.
Re:Ditch Nuclear and Save $860M with Grid Flexibility, U.K. ... by andyv on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @08:20AM (#25264858)
It would work at night, too.