News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why do I care the open web is dying? by tayo42 on Monday November 30, 2020 @09:19PM (#25261553)
> reddit is where I go to get on the ground crowdsourced recommendations

I would be careful about this on reddit. Subreddit communities are heavily influenced by fotm, everyone repeating the same thing(there's a word for this and i cant think of it...) Dissenting opinions to what ever is main stream gets downvoted. Reddit communities are also heavy on beginners. Those beginners often don't realize how much depth of knowledge they are missing.

It might be a place to bounce ideas off, but I would only go there after doing some of my own research. It should only be one tool of many.

In areas I consider myself knowledgeable, I see terrible advice given out. Often parroted by beginners. Like people in the headphone subreddit can give recommendations without listening to them. cscareerquestions is the blind leading the blind more often then not. There's no way to differentiate experience with someone fishing for upvotes or think they're being helpful by repeating someone else's advice.

I also think there's some astroturfing going on sometimes

Re:Why do I care the open web is dying? by TeMPOraL on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @06:21AM (#25264296)
Careful, yes. It's not a good idea to just pop up on Reddit and buy whatever the first thing you see them recommend is. You need to do some minimum amount of critical thinking. You need to spend some time browsing a given subreddit.

The idea behind using Reddit for product recommendation is the observation that an active community of enthusiast of some niche is hard to game by marketers - such community will try to moderate away spam, as it interferes with their regular discussion, and expert community members will be able to call astroturfers on their bullshit. It's orders of magnitude more reliable a source than in-store reviews and most review sites, as they're all thoroughly gamed and/or owned by marketers. But you do need a little bit of critical thinking to evaluate what you read there.

Re:Why do I care the open web is dying? by Threeve303 on Monday November 30, 2020 @09:57PM (#25261781)
> I also think there's some astroturfing going on sometimes

Marketing companies figured this out a long time ago. Even HN had a headline recently that was something like "use subreddits to drive app adoption".

Re:Why do I care the open web is dying? by BalinKing on Monday November 30, 2020 @09:42PM (#25261686)
> everyone repeating the same thing

Maybe "hive mind" is what you were thinking of (at least, I see it a lot in reference to Reddit)?

Re:Why do I care the open web is dying? by rei0 on Monday November 30, 2020 @10:25PM (#25261960)
I think it's called "echo chamber".
Re:Why do I care the open web is dying? by tayo42 on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @12:19AM (#25262584)
yes there it is, though the other is accurate too
Re:Why do I care the open web is dying? by LdSGSgvupDV on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @08:12PM (#25272185)
Another point is that reddit easily to have one side opinion. It is hard to take a look at top downvote replies in popular threads. Are there any reasons to make downvote unsearchable/un-sortable? It feels like an upvotes' justice censoring tool to control the trend. Who gains the upvotes who leads the crowd.
Re:Why do I care the open web is dying? by lame-robot-hoax on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @05:04AM (#25263926)
I mean, you can predict somewhat how headphones will sound based on a FR graph.