News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by foota on Monday November 30, 2020 @09:16PM (#25261530)
They developed a new rocket engine and the ability to land upright, both significant engineering challenges, which it seems is what the problem is currently for fusion (i.e., we need to build and iterate on things that mostly seem they should work)
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by mdorazio on Monday November 30, 2020 @09:33PM (#25261638)
I don't agree the problems are comparable at all. The original Merlin engines were modern iterations of proven technology and vertical landing rockets were already proven technology dating back many decades to the DC-X [1] and Apollo lunar lander. What SpaceX did was cut all the bullshit out of the space launch industry that had grown incredibly lazy due to lack of competitors and revolving doors with the government, and then modernize everything with iterative development. In comparison, commercially viable fusion has never been shown to work in the real world at all. The Raptor engine, however, really is a massive achievement and is somewhat comparable to developing fusion power. But if SpaceX had started with it, they probably would have failed due to how much time, money, and expertise it took to get working.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McDonnell_Douglas_DC-X

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by avmich on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @12:42AM (#25262698)
> The Raptor engine, however, really is a massive achievement and is somewhat comparable to developing fusion power.

Disagree, the theory of full-flow gas generators, and test bench results, were known for many years. At the same time with fusion we only have experience with uncontrolled one (bombs), or theory of how stars operate (and we can't reproduce that mechanism, not enough gravity). There is a lot more science to discover in fusion than in Raptors.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by fastball on Monday November 30, 2020 @09:58PM (#25261789)
Ok, so then someone should start a company that iterates on fission (proven tech like Merlin) and gets the cost of that way down and safety way up, then uses that momentum to work on fusion, which (like the Raptor engine) is a whole 'nother ball game, but you can still use some of the expertise from fission for fusion.

The analogy holds!

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by ubercore on Monday November 30, 2020 @11:32PM (#25262324)
I think fission to fusion is more like steam engine to jet engine. Fission can happen by _accident_ if you have the right materials at energy levels of just dropping something on something else [0].

Starting fusion isn't easy, but as I understand it, that's not even the hard part. Containment is the big deal, because of the energy needed.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demon_core

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by jabl on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @04:51AM (#25263869)
There's a saying that fission is like playing a mini-golf course where you have a flat surface peppered with holes, and every time you hit a hole you get ~2 new balls. Fusion is like a mini-golf course which is a volcano mountain with a tiny hole on the top.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by fastball on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @01:15AM (#25262872)
Isn't the Sun fusion happening by accident?
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by semi-extrinsic on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @02:20AM (#25263153)
Yeah, but the Sun only works because of its unfathomably massive size, compared to anything we can do on Earth.

If you take 800 cubic meters of plasma from the core of the Sun, about the same volume as ITER, it only produces 216 kW - comparable to the engine in your car.

And in that volume, you will have an average rate of 1500 hydrogen fusion reactions per second. Compared to ITER, this is something like twelve orders of magnitude slower. That is why ITER needs to go to much higher temperatures than the sun.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by pfdietz on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @05:14PM (#25270736)
You have made an error somewhere. 1500 fusion reactions per second is maybe 10^10 eV per second, which would be around a nanowatt.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by semi-extrinsic on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @06:22PM (#25271389)
Yeah, you are right there is a mistake. I made a typo in Avogadro's number. Sorry about that!

The power density is correct, but the number of reactions is too low by a factor of 10^10...

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by JoshuaDavid on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @01:46AM (#25263023)
Sure, and solar power is cheap fusion energy.

Getting fusion energy without gravitational confinement is the tricky bit.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by sudosysgen on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @01:31AM (#25262959)
Fission and fusion is a quantum leap. It's like going from the Babbage Differential Engine to a Ryzen 7 1700X.

You can't iterate your way from fission to fusion, but you can iterate your way from the Merlin to the Raptor.

The Raptor which, by the way, is not even that far ahead of what came before it.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by fastball on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @01:42AM (#25263003)
Don't actually think you can iterate from Merlin to Raptor.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by avmich on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @12:35PM (#25267467)
> Don't actually think you can iterate from Merlin to Raptor.

In some sense Earth science had practically do that - from Goddard's 1926 pressure-fed/piston pumps feed via von Braun's open loop of 1944, via Isayev-Melnikov staged combustion of 1949-1959 to Glushko's full-flow combustion of 1967.

Slow, and engines were designed from scratch. But still some iterations and evolution.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by vladTheInhaler on Monday November 30, 2020 @10:00PM (#25261800)
I don't think that landing on the moon with lunar gravity and no atmosphere is at all comparable to surviving hypersonic reentry speeds and landing on such a tiny target. And reading the Wikipedia article, it doesn't sound like the DC-X ever demonstrated a landing from orbit, which is most of the challenge.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by everyone on Monday November 30, 2020 @10:19PM (#25261925)
Space X have never landed any rockets from orbit. Only their 1st stage has landed, which mainly goes up, its nowhere near orbital velocity.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by vladTheInhaler on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @01:08PM (#25267868)
That's fair. Perhaps I should have said "from a trajectory that could plausibly lead it to orbit."
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by marvin on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @08:15AM (#25264826)
Go back five years, to December 2015, and you’d find most people on Hacker News deride SpaceX’s landing attemps as impossible at worst or economically infeasible at best, three weeks before they first succeeded.

Hopefully you (like me) were one of the ones cheering them on, but achievements that seem obvious in reterospect usually have had notoriously shaky statements about how obvious they were.

Obviously the proponents are vindicated today, but it becomes a dodgy game of definitions when talking about how everyone who really had any insight knew that it was inevitable.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by pfdietz on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @05:19PM (#25270793)
Here's an interesting news story about Airbus Defense and Space (formerly Astrium)'s reaction to SpaceX, in January 2014:

https://spacenews.com/38891a-hat-tip-to-spacex-as-rebranded-...

What's fascinating about this is how NO ONE was talking about them getting the first stage to be reusable. Musk's plan looks like it exploited this blind spot. Reusing the first stage was so obviously impossible that even with the evidence of nine first stage engines staring them in the face, they thought this was just to minimize development cost. It was only when the legs went on that the penny dropped.

And now, no one else will be able to repeat the free R&D flights that SpaceX got by trying to recover first stages off expendable launches sold at expendable launcher prices.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by marvin on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @06:19PM (#25271371)
Thanks for digging up the concrete data backing up my claim. I was certain that I correctly remembered every observer that counted being blindsided by SpaceX’s success, in spite of their announcing their progress and stating their intentions time and time again.

One really has to be meticulous to stay honest when looking at things in reterospect. And, by extension, when looking at lofty-sounding predictions about the future.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by ClumsyPilot on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @09:29AM (#25265440)
Well the opinions on Hackernews are only a little better than those on DailyMail when it comes to sibjects outside IT industry.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by mulmen on Monday November 30, 2020 @09:23PM (#25261577)
They weren't the first to build a new engine or an engine of that type or land upright. They just combined previous achievements in a better way. Their technology is incredible but it is all incremental improvements combined with a sustainable business model.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by yholio on Monday November 30, 2020 @09:33PM (#25261641)
Their major accomplishments were economic, not technological. Their crown jewel Raptor, applies full-flow staged combustion principles that were known and demonstrated on soviet test stands since the 60s.

Fusion power still needs to overcome fundamental, hard physics problems.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by mulmen on Monday November 30, 2020 @09:40PM (#25261670)
My understanding is that the physics are actually pretty well understood but it's just a matter of executing on them. Fusion is possible but we just need someone to actually... do it. Which AFAIK is the point of ITER.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by donor20 on Monday November 30, 2020 @11:11PM (#25262219)
ITER will NOT in any reasonable time frame actually do it, and will not be a commercial success.

Talk to someone in physics closer to this. The time scales ITER is operating on are so long term the tech is ancient by the the time they are actually operating it and the path to commercial power is - basically not there I think.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by mulmen on Monday November 30, 2020 @11:18PM (#25262262)
I don't think ITER was ever intended to be a commercial success and it doesn't have to be. It's literally named the International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor.

It is a research reactor. It goes first to prove it is at least possible to build a power producing reactor. That's all it has to do. Just exist.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by DubiousPusher on Monday November 30, 2020 @11:41PM (#25262373)
How can the tech be "ancient" if they are the first ones building it, even if slowly. There may be many new designs by the time they deliver on an older one but that hardly makes the tech "ancient".
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by dredds on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @03:15AM (#25263427)
Obsolete on Arrival is what's implied i think. If deuterium–tritium fusion experiments start sometime after 2035 then it's potentially "ancient tech" given the accelerating tech timelines (singularity) which is exponential in character.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by XorNot on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @05:10AM (#25263951)
You can't wave your hands, chant "singularity" or "exponential growth" and actually have made an argument. Someone has to do the research - the singularity is not coming in 2050.

Progress in computer science, and the absurd utility of data handling improvements to other fields, has created an extremely unrealistic expectation in the minds of computer tech adjacent professionals about how quickly technology can actually develop, because the core technology of computing (more transistors) had a long period of exponential improvement due to the nature of how it's produced (lithography on 2D surfaces). Feature size shrinks give you exponential improvements.

But that period is ending for computing - there's no more room left in the silicon chip regime to keep doing it much past 6nm. And progress in other fields enjoys no such advantages: cellular biology for example, can't exponentially increase the time it to takes to grow a culture. They also can't shrink it easily - scaling biological research generally involves just scaling in size - facilities, space, grad students, everything. It is much more linear - there are very few easy wins beyond what improved informatics handling gave us (and where we did get big wins was the same mechanism - the availability of cheap silicon handling led to a rush to look for ways to capitalize on cheap silicon handling).

There's a reason computing is powering better surveillance, but brain-computer interface technology is moving exactly as fast as there are people working in the field, doing experiments, developing technology and doing slow, uncool research like patch-clamping single cells or whatever. Because the fundamentals are diverse, and there is no one single technical improvement which gives you a big scaling improvement (and everyone is hoping they'll find one).

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by erk__ on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @02:58AM (#25263337)
The design of ITER was finished in 1998. Technology have changed a lot since then,although no one have built any near the size of it because of the expenses that are pretty much guaranteed to not give any money back.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by DubiousPusher on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @04:14PM (#25269975)
That's fine but to act like new small scale experiments and designs obsolete technology that has never before been developed at scale is silly and frankly runs contrary to how technological and scientific progress are made. I'll never understand the biases of theorists. They act as if all theory isn't deeply indebted to practical learnings. You don't commit to a project like ITER because you believe it will turn out a cutting edge solution to a problem. You do so because you believe that whatever happens, in the end you will harvest many learnings that are widely useful.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by tintor on Monday November 30, 2020 @09:34PM (#25261648)
First to land upright from orbital flight.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by mulmen on Monday November 30, 2020 @10:48PM (#25262091)
On top of the great points made by sibling comments the Apollo Lunar Modules landed propulsively from orbit with an additional party trick of having humans on board.

Also Blue Origin actually did propulsive sub-orbital landing from space to Earth before SpaceX, although admittedly from a lower altitude and velocity. Both came after the 1990s era Delta Clipper. Before that there were probably a lot of Apollo era test vehicles.

Each one got a bit higher and faster. This is the value SpaceX offers. They're doing the hard work of making things we know are possible also commercially viable.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by everyone on Monday November 30, 2020 @10:23PM (#25261948)
Not orbital. Sub-orbital. Only their 1st stage rocket has landed, which mainly goes up, its nowhere near orbital velocity.

They plan to land the 2nd stage of starship, which will have reached orbital speeds. But that is a huge challenge that they have not attempted yet.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by sudosysgen on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @01:33AM (#25262965)
When did SpaceX ever do a powered landing from orbital flight?

The first ones that did, by the way, are the Soviets in the early 70s.

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by mulmen on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @06:45AM (#25264393)
Do you mean on Earth? If you are talking about Soyuz, that was actually 1967!

If you mean space probes it’s actually more impressive, the Soviets landed a probe on the moon in 1966: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luna_9

Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by sudosysgen on Tuesday December 01, 2020 @10:26AM (#25265948)
Ah sorry, I meant in atmosphere! But you are of course right!
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by madengr on Monday November 30, 2020 @10:08PM (#25261859)
The retro-rockets on 1976 Viking lander in Mars don’t count? Of course that had a parachute to assist, but I think it was still going really fast.
Re:South Korea's fusion device KSTAR runs for 20 seconds at ... by mulmen on Monday November 30, 2020 @10:12PM (#25261877)
Sounds like the Russians actually did it in 1971?

Also since we are already speaking extra terrestrially Apollo 11 landed propulsively in 1969, with humans on board and it got back to orbit!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viking_1#Lander

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mars_3#Entry,_descent,_landing...