News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AlphaFold: a solution to a 50-year-old grand challenge in... by asdfasgasdgasdg on Monday November 30, 2020 @12:13PM (#25256128)
I have a related question about this. If experimental methods produce results around a score of 90, what is the baseline we are comparing the DeepMind results against? If the experimental error is equal to the observed DeepMind error, how can we say which one is actually more erroneous?
Re:AlphaFold: a solution to a 50-year-old grand challenge in... by mrDmrTmrJ on Monday November 30, 2020 @12:38PM (#25256448)
Excellent question. At somepoint, I think the only answer is, "have a bunch of different people run a bunch of experiments on the same protein."

The threshold for "real" in particle physics is +5 sigma. Which takes a lot of data.

Re:AlphaFold: a solution to a 50-year-old grand challenge in... by dnautics on Monday November 30, 2020 @11:46PM (#25262411)
you really can't compare stats like that. Those are independent, uncorrelated measurements. When you take RMSD measurements on a molecule they are not independent (for example, atoms near the core are less likely to be "inaccurate").
Re:AlphaFold: a solution to a 50-year-old grand challenge in... by radioactivist on Monday November 30, 2020 @12:54PM (#25256671)
I think it's that a score of >90 means the result is within the error bars of whatever particular experiment was chosen to be the "reference".
Re:AlphaFold: a solution to a 50-year-old grand challenge in... by IfOnlyYouKnew on Monday November 30, 2020 @03:29PM (#25258547)
The "experiments" here use X-Ray Crystallography. Like most methods of measuring anything, we have a pretty good idea of its accuracy under various conditions.

Think of it like satellite imagery of a tree: A score of zero would be a single green-ish pixel, while a score of 100 would show each leaf within the range it naturally moves in due to wind etc. (proteins tend to wiggle quite a bit under natural conditions, as well)

Re:AlphaFold: a solution to a 50-year-old grand challenge in... by 0-_-0 on Monday November 30, 2020 @12:26PM (#25256293)
That's a damn good question, it looks like we don't know how much above 90 AlphaFold is.
Re:AlphaFold: a solution to a 50-year-old grand challenge in... by cpeterso on Monday November 30, 2020 @12:39PM (#25256456)
And is it even meaningful for DeepMind to score better than experimental results? How are DeepMind’s results scored then?
Re:AlphaFold: a solution to a 50-year-old grand challenge in... by marcosdumay on Monday November 30, 2020 @12:46PM (#25256561)
Finding the energy of each configuration should be much easier than finding the lowest-energy configuration. Can that be calculated ab-initio or it is still too expensive?
Re:AlphaFold: a solution to a 50-year-old grand challenge in... by crispycrafter2 on Monday November 30, 2020 @02:57PM (#25258153)
The problem with ab-initio methods in this context is the sheer number of non-covalent interactions present in these large proteins. A simple protein would require a hybrid quantum mechanic/molecular mechanics simulation to even approximate the vibrational energy required to validate equilibrium.

These proteins are so massive that we often use Daltons [1] as an averaged measure of molecular weight.

Conceptually one of the most promising applications of quantum computing is theoretical chemistry, and we are only now starting to make progress in this avenue [2]. I anticipate it would require quantum computing to explicitly optimise large folded proteins.

1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dalton_(unit) 2. https://arxiv.org/abs/2004.04174