Re:Speaking of the British
by nradov on Sunday May 08, 2011 @01:09AM
(#2525307)
I have consistently found the dynamic, emotive people to be disastrous in crisis situations. They tend to act rashly without thinking through the consequences and often make things worse. When faced with a technical problem I prefer dispassionate experts who can apply a discipled, scientific approach and never get flustered.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I think I'm phrasing it wrong. I'm definitely not saying that people prone to histrionics are good performers, just people who show that they are concerned about the situation, have some leather in it, and want to fix it above all else seem to be the people that actually get it done the best.
A rational approach to actually solving the problem is definitely best, I agree.
A blank stare, followed by business as usual, is a non-starter in my opinion.
Depends on the crisis. For crises where you have a 'book' on the situation, dispassionate, by-the-numbers execution is important. For situations where you do not, somebody had better be ready to stand up and lead.
Both approaches are valuable, but they do not address the same problems.