News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Women, Income, and The Sexual Paradox: Explaining America... by CMartucci on Saturday May 07, 2011 @12:57PM (#2524045)
I didn't know so many people would have a problem with that sentence. I thought it was clear that I was merely playing devil's advocate. It's not horrible reasoning. It's merely a question that I thought should be raised.
Re:Women, Income, and The Sexual Paradox: Explaining America... by jeffdavis on Saturday May 07, 2011 @01:24PM (#2524119)
Granted, "free will" and "choice" are complex topics.

But it's confusing to use a word like "choose" and then immediately say "outside of their direct control".

On reflection, I think the point that you were trying to make was something like:

"Regardless of whether the cause is societal pressure, neurobiology, or personal choices, women are potentially suffering from lower pay."

I liked the article before the conclusion, however.

Re:Women, Income, and The Sexual Paradox: Explaining America... by CMartucci on Saturday May 07, 2011 @01:30PM (#2524139)
Lol. Well, perhaps I'll reword the conclusion. I suppose it was a bit confusing. I was arguing that a woman's "choice" could be caused/influenced by societal pressure or neurobiology. And either way, to what extent is this a robust "choice"? Personally, I believe that neurobiology is the cause of all our behavior. However, I think it is still worth bringing up the implications of that line of thought. As I said before, there are neurobiological reasons for racism. Of course, these reasons do not JUSTIFY racism, they merely EXPLAIN it. And so, in my conclusion, I wanted to bring up the issue -- "Although we may be able to explain lower pay, either through neurobiology, societal pressure, or otherwise, this does not necessarily justify it."
Re:Women, Income, and The Sexual Paradox: Explaining America... by jeffdavis on Saturday May 07, 2011 @01:58PM (#2524199)
Yes, that wording is much better.

Person1: "My house washed away!" Person2: "I have found the cause: it was that hurricane last night. My work here is done; glad I could help; you are very welcome."