Re:Rebuilding the Racket Compiler with Chez Scheme
by cwyers on Friday November 27, 2020 @09:59PM
(#25234843)
The reason for Racket and its large library to embrace a large standard is the amount of things that Racket doesn't have to implement itself because it's in the standard already.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Rebuilding the Racket Compiler with Chez Scheme
by bitwize on Friday November 27, 2020 @11:35PM
(#25235304)
That's not how standards work. The standard just specifies something; you still have to implement it, unless the standard supplies a reference implementation which you can make work with your code. There's a reason why the quasi-standards for extensions to Scheme are called Scheme Requests for Implementation.
Neither R6RS nor any other RnRS standard contain a reference implementation, so whether it's in R6RS or not, the Racket developers have to implement it. RnRS standards do tend to have a description of Scheme's formal semantics, and SRFI documents, by convention, contain a reference implementation of the proposed API where possible.