News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:56% of Americans have Internet data caps; FCC asked to in... by walkon on Friday May 06, 2011 @10:01PM (#2523051)
Why can't people apply non-internet concepts to the internet/ISPs? Do utilities give you unlimited electricity, gas, and water? Of course not. Does everyone who goes to McDonald's pay a flat fee of $5 and get as much as they want? Resources are scarce and the people who voluntarily provide them shouldn't be required by law to provide it infinitely without charging more or capping usage.
Re:56% of Americans have Internet data caps; FCC asked to in... by Dove on Friday May 06, 2011 @10:25PM (#2523083)
No one is saying caps, in principle, ought to be illegal, the argument you seem to be attacking.

The article is arguing that the caps are out of sync with the actual scarcity of the resource. Prices are rising and caps are dropping, even though bandwidth is becoming cheaper and more available. That suggests the caps aren't being used to make people pay for resources they use, but rather to trick people into spending money they didn't realize they'd be on the hook for. That's sneaky and skeezy.

It's like the banks that charge a $50 overdraft fee on each of six trivial transactions. No one is saying there shouldn't be a fee, but if it's turning into a significant profit stream, something's not right.

Re:56% of Americans have Internet data caps; FCC asked to in... by walkon on Friday May 06, 2011 @10:49PM (#2523105)
My point is also to counter the outrage over usage-based pricing. What is so unfair about the idea of ISPs charging per/KB similar to how an electric utility charges per/KWh?

Prices are rising for services and commodities in almost every industry. For instance, cotton has hit record highs this year, food is more expensive, gas is higher, etc. We're in an inflationary economy right now, so I don't think ISPs should be singled out for raising prices as their costs increase (e.g. they have to pay rising utility costs, salaries/benefits/health coverage, property taxes, etc). Perhaps what should be examined is change in net profit margins for ISPs that cap usage, but even if that rises, it is hard to know with certainty if the "sneaky and skeezy" "tricks" were the factor. One could argue if their tactics are indeed so "sneaky and skeezy" that they would loose business in the long run and negatively impact their profit margin.

Re:56% of Americans have Internet data caps; FCC asked to in... by matwood on Saturday May 07, 2011 @09:44AM (#2523731)
My point is also to counter the outrage over usage-based pricing. What is so unfair about the idea of ISPs charging per/KB similar to how an electric utility charges per/KWh?

I don't have any problem with usage based pricing. ISPs don't really want that either though. They want to push users to a high priced tier and then hope the users don't use the entire bucket each month.

Look at AT&T cell phone data plans for example. They used to have a $30 plan that was 'unlimited'. This plan really had a soft cap of 5GB, so $6/GB. I find that a very fair price. Then they changed to 2 plans, one for $15/250MB or $25/2GB. I bet they did some analysis and found out that most users use 300-500MB/month so they made the plans to push people into the higher plan with the hopes they would not use the data. If they were really concerned about high usage they would have just moved to a flat $6/GB (or something similar), but then most people would ended up paying $6-$12/month.

Re:56% of Americans have Internet data caps; FCC asked to in... by benmccann on Friday May 06, 2011 @11:29PM (#2523145)
I'm not sure utilities are a good comparison point for two reasons. The first is that the marginal cost of internet data is near zero while the marginal cost of electricity generation is not. Secondly, utilities generally are more highly regulated than ISPs.

The reason it can be distasteful when an ISP raises its rates or limits its services is that ISPs often have a monopoly over many of their customers. At best most people get to choose from a duopoly, so the ISPs don't really have to compete in a free market.

Re:56% of Americans have Internet data caps; FCC asked to in... by walkon on Saturday May 07, 2011 @12:06AM (#2523187)
The marginal costs of commercial software is even lower, but most vendors charge in a mostly linear manner; it's not like they decrement their prices for each sale they make to keep a steady cost-to-price ratio. Why should they? If enough people want to still voluntarily purchase their product/service, they should continue to try and make as much money as possible. If their are few good options, then the market is ripe for competition to help bring the incumbents back to offering better values.

Isn't this a site revolving around entrepreneurs in IT? Doesn't everyone want to make more money then they spend?

Re:56% of Americans have Internet data caps; FCC asked to in... by jbri on Saturday May 07, 2011 @01:11AM (#2523248)
If the market was actually open for competition, then there would be alternatives and no-one would complain about caps, they'd just move to another provider.

The fact that bitching about the caps is people's only option should tip you off to the fact that the market is not, in fact, open.

Re:56% of Americans have Internet data caps; FCC asked to in... by walkon on Saturday May 07, 2011 @03:28AM (#2523361)
There is definitely competition, but even if there wasn't, that would mean that the existing provider was good enough. What's stopping more alternatives from appearing besides this? Probably looming legislation more than anything. If you really hate it, instead of spending your energy lobbying for regulations, go start your own ISP that gives everyone the world for a lower flat rate. I'm sure you'll stay in business for a long time.
Re:56% of Americans have Internet data caps; FCC asked to in... by henrikschroder on Saturday May 07, 2011 @04:29AM (#2523404)
In countries where there is actual competition between ISPs, such as Sweden, and other parts of Europe, there are no caps. And our ISPs don't seem to suffer for it. I'm sure they'd love to have caps, but the first one to do it will just start bleeding customers, and none of them can afford that since the market is saturated.

I have a throttle cap on my mobile internet though, I can use as much internet as I like on my iPhone for a flat fee, but if I go over 5GB in a month, they may throttle my speed for the next month. That's pretty fair, I guess, but they're building out 4G now with even faster mobile internet, so those caps are probably going to disappear slowly as people move over to newer technology with more bandwidth than the current 3G/EDGE systems.

Stop being an apologist.

Re:56% of Americans have Internet data caps; FCC asked to in... by jasonlotito on Saturday May 07, 2011 @09:33AM (#2523719)
> In countries where there is actual competition between ISPs

How do you define competition between ISPs?

Re:56% of Americans have Internet data caps; FCC asked to in... by henrikschroder on Saturday May 07, 2011 @01:09PM (#2524076)
Where I am, I can choose between nine different ADSL providers, one cable provider, and about six different mobile broadband providers. All of them want me to switch to them, and they differ slightly in pricing, bundling, triple-play, customer service, speed, etc.
Re:56% of Americans have Internet data caps; FCC asked to in... by jasonlotito on Saturday May 07, 2011 @03:07PM (#2524316)
That's not what I'm asking. I have multiple providers of DSL internet, cable, and mobile providers, all with varying services, pricing, etc. Each one applies caps.

Where you are, are their lies that affect providers in that area? Or is it all pure competition?

Did those 9 ADSL providers all lay their own line, or is their laws in effect that make those providers lease their lines out to other providers?

Basically, is it pure competition?

Re:56% of Americans have Internet data caps; FCC asked to in... by henrikschroder on Saturday May 07, 2011 @03:56PM (#2524439)
The copper network is owned by TeliaSonera, the former state telephone monopoly, but they were forced to open that up to competitors so anyone could install DSLAMs in the phone stations, etc. There's competing national fiber networks as well, so no ISP has a stranglehold on the DSL market.

There's no competition and choice for cable though, you have the cable company you have, and that's it.

For GSM networks, there's three separate, and two or three 3G networks, so there's competition there as well.

In a few months my house is gonna be hooked up to the city fiber network, at which point I can choose from another bunch of ISPs.

Re:56% of Americans have Internet data caps; FCC asked to in... by falldowngoboom on Friday May 06, 2011 @10:42PM (#2523098)
The ISPs also don't treat it as a proper utility. If I don't use it for a month, I still have to pay my full monthly rate.
Re:56% of Americans have Internet data caps; FCC asked to in... by walkon on Friday May 06, 2011 @10:52PM (#2523109)
Yeah it goes both ways. The users who barely use their internet connection, such as grandmas that check their email and look up a recipe a few times a week, are subsidizing the users who are streaming Netflix in high def for 3 hours a night.
Re:56% of Americans have Internet data caps; FCC asked to in... by runningdogx on Friday May 06, 2011 @11:53PM (#2523171)
I'll pick on at&t uverse since that's what I've got, and since they're the latest to join the transfer cap party.

Those grandmas are not paying $65/mo for the top service tier. They are paying $35/mo for 3Mbit/s lowest-tier uverse service, and they still get a transfer cap of 250GB.

Streaming netflix users, who are pretty much all going to be in the top tier or two of service (24Mbit/s or 18Mbit/s) get pinched by the same cap. 250GB is 3.2% utilization of an 24Mbit/s download link, over a month, btw.

Even in some alternate universe where caps make sense, the least AT&T could do is grade the caps by line speed. It seems to me like I'm subsidizing grannie's transfer allowance, even if she doesn't fully use it.

Since the primary issue is traffic congestion at peak usage times, the obvious solution is to rate limit heavy users, rather than punishing them with hard caps which indiscriminately targets users who transfer lots of data in off hours.

Given all that, why does AT&T cap all uverse tiers the same? The first explanation that comes to mind is that they know if they drop the caps too much for lower tiers, because despite what they claim 250GB really isn't that much, they'll start cutting into too many grannies' modest internet usage. They want to keep their low-end customers from being hurt by lower caps, but they want to gouge their higher-end customers for going over the same caps.

And why do they cap instead of rate limiting heavy users? Rate limiting doesn't make them money. Caps might (though they will lose some customers over this outrage, and others will cut back usage or service tiers, so AT&T might even lose money overall).

Re:56% of Americans have Internet data caps; FCC asked to in... by orblivion on Friday May 06, 2011 @10:09PM (#2523061)
People seem to assume that it's out of "greed" that they're doing this. Just look at how much the executives are making, and all that. They don't seem to buy scarcity as a legitimate argument.
Re:56% of Americans have Internet data caps; FCC asked to in... by Klinky on Saturday May 07, 2011 @03:35AM (#2523369)
Artificial scarcity is not real scarcity. When you have the ISPs taking federal money and blowing it on themselves, merging with each other to lower competition levels, buying up media assets & suing communities who try to do things on their own terms, you start to see how underhanded a lot of the telecoms practices are.