The procedures used in NYC aren't drastically different from Singapores', but the key difference is that Manhattan cannot close its borders to the rest of the 50 US States.
When people ask for a strong government in the US, its' within that context. They want a government that could enforce quarantines between different states, locking people into one state or another till the virus burns itself out. That's the way it worked in China, but is legally impossible to do in the US.
The US can have minor quarantines (an apartment, a city block, etc.) but we can't legally quarantine a whole city, much less states.
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/08/nyregion/nursing-homes-de...
'A state directive sent thousands of Covid-19 patients into nursing homes'
yep, no difference at all
Centuries of free travel between states has made the borders very porous and mostly just a legal concept. There are so many minor road crossings between, say, New York and Pennsylvania that it would be impossible to secure.
Participating in an underground rave in Singapore would result in lashes.
What’s enough power? A government-mandated lockdown is legally impossible in Japan but they have managed to keep COVID cases within a number that can be handled by their medical system.