News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple not providing LGPL webkit source code for latest iO... by rewqwefqwerf on Friday May 06, 2011 @01:25PM (#2521665)
You just need the copyright owners to sue now. The copyright holders can also ask the SFLC do it for them, I'm sure they would love it.
Re:Apple not providing LGPL webkit source code for latest iO... by mechanical_fish on Friday May 06, 2011 @01:45PM (#2521754)
One doesn't have to start with a lawsuit. One starts with a nice polite letter, on actual paper, to Apple's legal department reminding them of their LGPL obligations and pointing out that they're past deadline and perhaps they should poke the relevant engineering team?

Then if that gets no satisfaction you have your lawyer send the same letter. Then a nastier letter. Only then do you begin to think about preparing a lawsuit, which is expensive and probably overkill.

What you don't do is put up a passive-aggressive blog post. This post doesn't even tell us how many letters have been sent, or by whom, or to whom, or when. Have we even asked the support folks or the engineers, let alone Apple legal?

I can barely find the stomach to blame Apple's engineering team for prioritizing strict and timely license compliance somewhere below: Making their boss Steve Jobs happy, releasing features that paying customers care about, and sleeping. Fortunately, it is not my job to blame them. It is the job of Apple's legal department to blame them. Has anyone asked Apple's legal department?

Re:Apple not providing LGPL webkit source code for latest iO... by gatlin on Friday May 06, 2011 @02:16PM (#2521886)
"I can barely find the stomach to blame Apple's engineering team for prioritizing strict and timely license compliance somewhere below: Making their boss Steve Jobs happy, releasing features that paying customers care about, and sleeping."

Sleep is an important function the brain and body must perform to survive; I would never advocate sleep deprivation.

However, no, Mr Jobs and everyone else can wait as there is a legally binding license governing the release of the code. This is a rare completely black and white issue. The binary is released without the source -> license violation.

Re:Apple not providing LGPL webkit source code for latest iO... by kalleboo on Friday May 06, 2011 @03:16PM (#2522118)
If they don't want to spend their time complying with the software license, then they're free to not use open source licensed code in their products. Microsoft do just that, and they never have to worry about compliance issues.

I don't think Apple would appreciate it if I downloaded iWork and instead of paying them said "Promoting strict and timely license compliance falls somewhere below sleeping".

Re:Apple not providing LGPL webkit source code for latest iO... by mechanical_fish on Friday May 06, 2011 @03:47PM (#2522206)
It is true: Apple will not appreciate it at all if you pirate iWork. But will they sue you?

Does anyone have a news story about Apple suing the (many, many) Apple software pirates? So far as I've heard, they don't even send very many nasty letters. Presumably not because they don't believe in paying for software, but because it's strategically unwise.

Anyway, if Apple fails to respond in timely fashion to a series of inquiries they can, indeed, eventually be sued, and maybe that will even be the best move. Perhaps a suit against Google will proceed at the same time:

http://www.electronista.com/articles/11/03/25/google.not.sha...

Though in that case, as well, I doubt it will come to that.

(One of the many virtues of starting your own business is that you soon learn all about the practical limitations of contract law. People violate the letter of your contracts all the time. What are you going to do about it? The law is a relatively blunt instrument; it is expensive and difficult to bring it into play, often more difficult than your unpaid invoice is worth.)

Re:Apple not providing LGPL webkit source code for latest iO... by jrockway on Friday May 06, 2011 @04:08PM (#2522282)
Perhaps a suit against Google will proceed at the same time

Indeed. It seems like applications that have code from non-Google employees have changed, as well as the Linux kernel itself.

Re:Apple not providing LGPL webkit source code for latest iO... by Aissen on Saturday May 07, 2011 @08:19AM (#2523665)
FUD : every GPL bit of Honeycomb has been released since January.
Re:Apple not providing LGPL webkit source code for latest iO... by jrockway on Saturday May 07, 2011 @08:42PM (#2524967)
Yes, you're right.
Re:Apple not providing LGPL webkit source code for latest iO... by alecco on Friday May 06, 2011 @01:35PM (#2521714)
It's a hard place. If they sue, they will be blamed as hardcore radicals. Remember most of the tech journalists depend on advertising.
Re:Apple not providing LGPL webkit source code for latest iO... by ekidd on Friday May 06, 2011 @01:42PM (#2521744)
If you hold copyrights on your software, it's not radical to ask people to refrain from republishing it without a license. That's the central goal of copyright law, and not a new idea invented by the FSF.
Re:Apple not providing LGPL webkit source code for latest iO... by perlgeek on Friday May 06, 2011 @04:54PM (#2522451)
Mr. Welte's approach so far has been to talk to the companies first, and only sued if there has been absolutely no (or negative) response.

I think the blog post is part of the "not yet suing" process too, it tries to build a bit of pressure on Apple in the hope that no lawsuit will be necessary.