News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Java Verbal Expressions by Tainnor on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @09:28PM (#25216322)
In the parent's suggestion, you still have immutable objects. "VerbalExpression()" is a valid regex, namely the empty one. Every subsequently called method concatenates some new regex onto the receiver and thus builds a new regex (since regular expressions are closed under concatenation).

Builders are used in Java* when you have an object which is invalid without passing in a bunch of parameters, but you don't want to have to remember the order of the parameters. But this is not one of these cases.

There is one drawback, however: you do have to compile the regex into a FSA at some point and it wouldn't be good to do that for every intermediate regex. So I assume that the compilation happens in the "build" step. They could have just called it "compile", though.

* named parameters in constructors seem a better alternative in every language that supports them, e.g. Kotlin

Re:Java Verbal Expressions by stickfigure on Thursday November 26, 2020 @12:45AM (#25217222)
Furthermore, with immutable objects there's no need to to have any public constructors at all.

`REGEX.startOfLine().then("http")...`

Since the start object is immutable, there's no reason to create new ones. Here's an example of this pattern applied to HTTP (my project):

https://github.com/stickfigure/hattery

Avoiding repeated Pattern.compile() is a good point though.