News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Help Ron Conway Abolish Stock Option Taxes in SF by drusenko on Friday May 06, 2011 @12:38PM (#2521473)
This is not a tax cut. San Francisco is the only major city in the US that taxes the company for an employee's personal gain on stock options.

This is eliminating a tax that was very, very poorly thought out as it effectively precludes any company from going public in the city of San Francisco. A company doing an $100M IPO might effectively be required to pay all $100M raised to the city of San Francisco as tax on the stock options gains of employees.

Discuss the merits of tax cuts elsewhere -- this is an obvious situation where this tax never should have been in the first place, and will be doing a considerable amount of harm to San Francisco if it is not repealed.

Re:Help Ron Conway Abolish Stock Option Taxes in SF by jeffreymcmanus on Friday May 06, 2011 @01:28PM (#2521681)
If you're advocating the removal of a tax, then yes, it's a tax cut. Whether it does harm to San Francisco or not is absolutely worth discussing. Let's start by asking where the city will make up the revenues it loses from removing this tax. Or is your solution to lay off more teachers?
Re:Help Ron Conway Abolish Stock Option Taxes in SF by drusenko on Friday May 06, 2011 @02:13PM (#2521870)
San Francisco does not currently enforce this tax, and it does not currently collect any revenues from it, so there is no revenue to be made up. No one was even aware of it until it was discovered recently.
Re:Help Ron Conway Abolish Stock Option Taxes in SF by jeffreymcmanus on Friday May 06, 2011 @02:18PM (#2521896)
Which makes its repeal a priority why, then?
Re:Help Ron Conway Abolish Stock Option Taxes in SF by drusenko on Friday May 06, 2011 @02:21PM (#2521906)
Because a lot of SF-based startups are looking to go public in the next few years. This has not been the case before.
Re:Help Ron Conway Abolish Stock Option Taxes in SF by jeffreymcmanus on Friday May 06, 2011 @02:35PM (#2521957)
So this is a tax cut for millionaires, then. Got it.
Re:Help Ron Conway Abolish Stock Option Taxes in SF by drusenko on Friday May 06, 2011 @02:52PM (#2522033)
If you want to blindly support any tax because it's a tax, and blindly hate any company that makes money because it's "an evil corporation", you are free to do so.

But it's abundantly clear by the facts in this situation that this is a net positive for San Francisco.

Re:Help Ron Conway Abolish Stock Option Taxes in SF by tptacek on Friday May 06, 2011 @03:46PM (#2522203)
If you want to alienate people from your point of view, caricature their own views. The person you're responding to doesn't seem to support taxation for taxation's sake, and doesn't seem to believe companies that make money are "evil".
Re:Help Ron Conway Abolish Stock Option Taxes in SF by drusenko on Friday May 06, 2011 @07:03PM (#2522810)
I agree, that response was out of line on my part. There were many better ways to phrase that.
Re:Help Ron Conway Abolish Stock Option Taxes in SF by kovar on Friday May 06, 2011 @01:31PM (#2521695)
Yet, despite the taxes, companies keep starting up in San Francisco. Maybe some people in SF don't want a Google-plex in the city? If you want to argue that it is bad for the city, post commentary from someone who isn't an investor in startups.
Re:Help Ron Conway Abolish Stock Option Taxes in SF by drusenko on Friday May 06, 2011 @02:23PM (#2521918)
I am not an investor in startups, I'm running one. I have the same perspective: We are more than happy to pay San Francisco's unusual payroll tax, but this tax on employee options would force us to move out of the city in a few years.

If your argument is that you don't want startups in San Francisco, that's a very fair position to hold, but it's not what we're discussing.

Re:Help Ron Conway Abolish Stock Option Taxes in SF by tptacek on Friday May 06, 2011 @03:53PM (#2522228)
The likelihood that this tax would drive startups out of the entire SFBA seems very low. Meanwhile, the tiny city of San Francisco proper is likely to remain well stocked with upwardly mobile tech company employees whether their employers are in SOMA or San Mateo.
Re:Help Ron Conway Abolish Stock Option Taxes in SF by drusenko on Friday May 06, 2011 @06:58PM (#2522788)
> The likelihood that this tax would drive startups out of the entire SFBA seems very low.

Absolutely agree. The likelihood that it would drive startups out of San Francisco proper is very high. We are discussing what the city of San Francisco needs to do to not force companies to move out of the city.

> Meanwhile, the tiny city of San Francisco proper is likely to remain well stocked with upwardly mobile tech company employees whether their employers are in SOMA or San Mateo.

Also likely, although there won't be as many of them. Another big issue is that the city of San Francisco will lose out on significant tax revenue from companies based here, since they will be forced to leave.

Re:Help Ron Conway Abolish Stock Option Taxes in SF by _delirium on Friday May 06, 2011 @09:54PM (#2523039)
Wouldn't both proposals address that? One appears to want to repeal it entirely, while the other proposal would cap the tax at $750,000 annually, so both would remove the potential of owing $100m in taxes for an IPO.