Re:Journal rejects studies contradicting precognition
by tokenadult on Friday May 06, 2011 @11:34AM
(#2521225)
Richard Wiseman, interviewed for the submitted article, is a psychologist who studies human cognitive biases. His concern regarding Bem's purported studies on precognition is that if journals reject studies showing no effect, while accepting flawed studies appearing to show precognition, this results in a file drawer problem
in which publication bias among the published studies will then skew any subsequent attempt at meta-analysis of the published studies. The file drawer effect is of particular concern in meta-analysis of purported extrasensory perception.
By the way, Wiseman is perhaps best known online as the author of the Colour-changing Card Trick website, featuring videos of an experiment that demonstrates selective attention in human perception.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Publication_bias#The_file_drawe...
in which publication bias among the published studies will then skew any subsequent attempt at meta-analysis of the published studies. The file drawer effect is of particular concern in meta-analysis of purported extrasensory perception.
http://www.skepdic.com/filedrawer.html
By the way, Wiseman is perhaps best known online as the author of the Colour-changing Card Trick website, featuring videos of an experiment that demonstrates selective attention in human perception.
http://www.quirkology.com/USA/Video_ColourChangingTrick.shtm...
If you haven't seen the video before, it is well worth watching.
I hope the more responsible journals of psychology will step up their efforts to publish commentaries on the study design
http://norvig.com/experiment-design.html
of ESP studies and publish in general more studies showing failures of replication of earlier study findings.