Re:Open Source Design – community of designers and devs for ...
by LexSiga on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @04:42PM
(#25214611)
I did not realized that aesthetic was not correlated with function. Probably a clear visual understanding to the actual value of something is meaningless, I suppose.
Re:Open Source Design – community of designers and devs for ...
by amitlzkpa on Sunday November 29, 2020 @01:16PM
(#25246817)
I think that question is in itself a fundamental part of UX design and research. Designs are better assessed with a context - so design that is bland for one group could be read as being elegantly minimal by another, and the opposite.
A big part of UX research is figuring out the user base and making designs conducive for your target.
Re:Open Source Design – community of designers and devs for ...
by lmilcin on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @06:03PM
(#25215269)
You should know better. You use Hacker News. This is as barebones as it is possible and yet lacks nothing of the function.
Re:Open Source Design – community of designers and devs for ...
by LexSiga on Thursday November 26, 2020 @07:54AM
(#25219601)
That is arguable, at best it is functional enough so that people can use it, at worst it is not functional for squat and it is mostly dominant because of the incubator attached to it.
In fact I wonder the rate of drop vs new user retention as it is hard to follow a thread, there is no clarity in the headline differentiations... it is really a tough argument to say that it lacks nothing and / or is a good example of function over design...
People who want to create actual value for other people, don't spend time endlessly polishing look and feel of their landing page.
The content of this is informational value and networking for people, not polished graphics.
Companies can throw money in design because they get revenue from it. Individual open source contributors who are not paid for their effort don't get revenue from the design but rather reward from the actual value they provide to other people.