News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Protect domains that don’t send email by derefr on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @11:04AM (#25210649)
The real trick would be if intermediary MTA servers could make the assumption that any domain without SPF/DKIM/etc. has the same intent ("I'm not supposed to be used for sending email") as a domain that explicitly has these "no-email" records. We could eliminate a huge swathe of spam senders from the web in a single stroke. (Right now we already apply this heuristic, but the output is just a signal for spam classifiers at the receiver, rather than a "drop the mail on the floor" signal at intermediates, the way that e.g. DNSRBLs are.)

If we did make this "you don't intend to send email if you don't have the secure-origin records" assumption, how much would that break email as a system? What old email servers are sitting around sending unsigned mail, that we want to protect/preserve the functioning of (in the same way we keep Internet-realm HTTP transport around in browsers to preserve access to old HTTP-only Web1.0 servers?)

Re:Protect domains that don’t send email by fanzhang on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @11:49AM (#25211224)
Your solution would work well if everyone (or nearly all people) agreed to migrate to it.

It may need to be in a few steps. The first step might be, for a 5 year period, mail clients display a warning saying the sending domain doesn't have the correct SPF records. Then after that, those mail clients dropped those emails.

Overall, the cleverness of the OP solution is that it uses to current system to make the next iterative step in solving the problem in a backwards compatible way.

If we could break backwards compatibility, I think we can solve a large number of issues with email wholesale.

Re:Protect domains that don’t send email by ryan29 on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @01:04PM (#25212151)
It would be easier to add something like a `forbid` policy to DMARC IMO, since you'd want to set up DMARC to monitor spoof attempts anyway. A simple `p=forbid,sp=forbid` (not real options) in DMARC would be ideal.

forbid - all mail is forbidden regardless of DMARC alignment

Re:Protect domains that don’t send email by rogueresearch on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @11:47AM (#25211194)
There are many servers still not using DKIM, as it requires a server/software update. But SPF is super easy, requiring only DNS changes. Could probably do as you suggest looking at only SPF.