HP/etc can't even get windows working correctly on a device that ships with windows. That is fundamentally what the article is about (the OS pref requests not being honored properly).
Its because HP/Dell/etc aren't really providing any real validation above the underlying ODM anymore. So whether the S3/whatever mode actually works is more a function of whether intel/amd and their bios provider insyde/ami/etc managed to get the option hooked up at all. So if you happen to enable S3 with some funny device and it doesn't come out of standby properly, then sure its a bug, you have to disable that device or disable S3.
But what really happens with the HP/etc laptops is you don't have the choice. Which is why you see endless complaints about modern standby issues on their "windows" devices despite running the supported OS. If the end user could just go and ignore the MS recommendations and disable modern standby on a laptop class device they likely would be much happier. Having the machine work reliably vs download email when the lid is closed is an easy choice.
In summary, the "value add" the big OEM's are adding is product segmentation by removing options the underlying technology providers ship by default.
Nobody thinks that. Laptops are expensive.
> From end-user perspective it's not nice but, it makes sense from a business perspective
Lots of deplorable things make sense from a business perspective. That's a very low bar to clear. "Intel's actions aren't literally counterproductive to their short-term interests". Yes, and so? They're not literally motivated by spite for their users. Is that supposed to make it better?
My non sw developer friends look for Windows laptops in the 300-400 Euro range. Things with flexible keyboards, maybe still 768p screens, a large HDD plus possibly a small SSD, 8 GB RAM, i3 or i5, a couple of USB ports, one HDMI. That's all they need.
If I have to explain them why my laptop costs plus than 1000 more than that I only tell them that it's for work, every day all the time.
For people who know and buy what they need, they're indeed expensive but, some consumers see computers as consumable entities. They buy a machine, use it 2-3 years and buy a new one then. This is my experience at the least. On the contrary, I tend to use every device I own 7-10 years before replacing.
> Lots of deplorable things make sense from a business perspective. That's a very low bar to clear. ... Is that supposed to make it better?
Saying that doesn't mean I support business interests over legitimate user needs but, businesses are greedy entities which always want more money so, they always follow the path which brings more money. It doesn't make any better either. I want to be able to buy any laptop and/or device I want and change the software stack and tune it the way I wish however, as we see today, this freedom is attacked more and more.
Unless consumer choice generates more profits (which is unlikely), we won't see that trend change much.
These settings and multi-os compatibility is generally reserved for enterprise level devices (EliteBook, XPS/Precision, Thinkapd) where these options both will be used and result in more sales.
From end-user perspective it's not nice but, it makes sense from a business perspective since most of the people doesn't care about their disposable laptops' Linux compatibility. "If it works, it works. If it doesn't, I'll buy a new one" they think.