News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by Imnimo on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @04:19PM (#25203114)
How do you differentiate an event that is very improbable and so takes a billion years from an event that is inevitable, but requires many prerequisites, and so takes a billion years?

The article seems to simply assume the former model ("We assume that once an evolutionary transition is possible (i.e., once the previous transition has occurred), it occurs at a constant average rate λi, so that each ti is exponentially distributed with an expected transition time of βi = 1/λi"), but that feels unjustified to me. Is it really the case that the transition from prokaryote to eukaryote was equally likely at any time, and things simply sat stagnant for a billion years until one day life got lucky?

Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by monkeycantype on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @06:53PM (#25204414)
This doesn't contradict the conclusion of the paper, it makes no difference as to whether we're going to find anybody we can have a conversation with, ("hey, how annoying is light speed?") but I think our definition for simple and complex life is off.

eg "more likely to find simple life on Mars."

That ape and octopus exist, says that earth didn't win the intelligence lottery, we are watching the long slow grind of compound interest.

When you look at our world we see that the lipid bilayer is preserved, that rna is preserved in every living thing, but eyes have evolved independently many times. That the last common ancestor of octopus and human was a little wriggly thing, leads me to believe that forming a boundary between self and non self is hard (the bilayer), that forming a system of heredity is hard (first rna then dna). That the accumulation of processes that use energy, resources and information from the environment in new ways is a long relentless grind. The basic body form, multicellularity and a gut were, big difficult changes, but maybe intelligence is just paint on a hard won foundation.

Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by joe_the_user on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @08:40PM (#25205085)
Yeah, in the discussion of "where is the intelligent life", you seldom see the argument that it really does takes 11+ billion years to produce that intelligence life. With a universe "only" 13 billion years old and possibly chaotic, this factor, rather than any specific "filter", might why we're not seeing any other intelligent life.
Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by CryptoPunk on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @11:12PM (#25205967)
Consistent with that, evidence suggests that it may have taken billions of years for the precursor molecules of the first Earth-based life to emerge/evolve:

https://www.technologyreview.com/2013/04/15/113741/moores-la...

Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by joe_the_user on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @02:49PM (#25213470)
Thanks, I remembered the article but couldn't find the link. This is a really neat argument.
Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by Nbox9 on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @02:47AM (#25206844)
Where are you getting the 11 billion years from, when Earth is 4.5 billion years old?
Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by tuatoru on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @03:00AM (#25206913)
The Earth is made of elements that were formed in supernovas.

We had to have several generations of stars formed out of the remains of older stars that blew themselves apart, to have more than trace amounts of any element apart from hydrogen and helium.

Earliest you could get rocky planets is probably a couple of billion years after the Big Bang. But more time is better.

Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by sampo on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @04:56PM (#25203400)
> an event that is inevitable, but requires many prerequisites, and so takes a billion years?

In support of this idea, the Cambrian explosion of large (large relative to microbial life) multicellular organisms happened immediately after the 2 billion years of work by blue-green algae had produced enough oxygen into the atmosphere to make larger organisms possible.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxidation_Event

https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2010/12/101217145647.h...

Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by AgentME on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @12:25AM (#25206252)
The article mentions that multicellular life is something that's known to have separately evolved at least 40 times, so it's probably not a useful evolutionary step to compare to ones that only happened once.
Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by arp242 on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @02:57AM (#25206894)
While it made complex life possible, at the same time the introduction of oxygen also killed a lot of lifeforms and was a mass extinction. It's not inconceivable that with slightly different circumstances it could have just have wiped out all life. The development of (complex) life seems like a really fine balance.
Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by sideshowb on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @06:25PM (#25204232)
I guess it all depends on how you balance occam's razor against abusing the anthropic principle.
Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by hnracer on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @04:54PM (#25203381)
Precisely. Something taking astoundingly long to evolve isn't conclusive evidence that it's highly improbable (although it might suggest it). It could very well be highly probable. One reason is as you mention is prerequisites. Another reason could be that the solution is deep in the search tree, and while it takes ages to find it, the search algorithm will eventually do so. Consider a global optimizer running on a concave surface for a long period of time, all it needs is time.
Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by hnracer on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @09:41PM (#25205443)
Just realized that the eye is a counterexample to their assumption. Took three billion years to evolve but is easy to do so as we've seen it evolve independently many times.
Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by joe_the_user on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @06:29PM (#25204259)
How do you differentiate an event that is very improbable and so takes a billion years from an event that is inevitable, but requires many prerequisites, and so takes a billion years?

I suspect that' gnawing for any research like this. But I could suggest that if we can show that a lot of fundamental changes have come from external shock rather than internal processes, then we might be closer. Further, if the theory of "puncture equilibrium" is true[1], that this would tend to be the case. If we can show that many evolutionary steps involved such external shocks, then we might be closer to this also.

The question would be whether external shocks inevitably produce advances or whether such advances are indeed lucky.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punctuated_equilibrium

Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by AgentME on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @12:27AM (#25206262)
Punctuated equilibrium doesn't really change the calculations involved in the article. Either mutations happen randomly on their own, or random events cause bursts of mutations to happen. The burstiness doesn't matter much when you zoom out enough.
Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by joe_the_user on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @01:03AM (#25206396)
Punctured equilibrium can matter if fundamentally new adaptation happen only or primarily with external disruptions. Mammals replaced reptiles after a mass extinction event cause by a meteor - another world might not regular meteors or might have too many.

The question is how non-earth world might fail, right.

Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by AgentME on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @01:26AM (#25206475)
It doesn't matter to the equations whether you're modeling the chance that a mutation happens on its own, or the chance that an event happens that causes the mutation. You would use the same equation to model either of those.
Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by AgentME on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @12:49AM (#25206338)
If the transitions were inevitable given the time they took here, then we would expect to see the transitions happen concurrently throughout the planet in many separate instances. But we see a number of important transitions that happened exactly once on Earth.
Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by galgalesh on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @07:01AM (#25208327)
Not necessarily. A number of stages in the evolution of life require a planet devoid of more complex life forms. Spontaneous generation of cells, for example, requires very high doses of molecules that more complex life forms eat.
Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by fotdutah on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @08:44AM (#25209122)
Also worth pointing out that this applies to some potential 'Great Filter' events that we haven't yet encountered. If intelligent cultures don't explore the universe because they destroy their own planets in destructive wars as soon as they have that level of technology, then conditional on our existing, we should expect to be the first such culture to evolve on our planet. If on the other hand, most intelligent cultures neglect to explore the universe because they are busy with art, contemplation or hedonism, we might expect to exist in a world where hyperintelligent dinosaurs, frogs and cephalopods are already sitting around enjoying these things. The fact that they aren't means that maybe our current stage of evolution was hard to reach.
Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by marshray on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @04:49PM (#25203342)
Yeah.

This looks to me like a hubristic level of extrapolation from a single data point.

Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by lopmotr on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @01:44AM (#25206548)
Why hubristic? Because he did it? What would a non-hubristic attempt to estimate the prevalence of life in the universe look like, short of actually finding aliens?
Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by marshray on Wednesday December 02, 2020 @03:40PM (#25281274)
I said 'hubristic' because it seemed to me that the inability to draw conclusions about the cosmos from our own (single data point) limited perspective was a fundamental limitation of the human condition.
Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by enkid on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @04:36PM (#25203244)
It also seems to assume that there is only one "path" to "observer" status. For example, could there be an alternative to Eukaryote cells that would allow equivalent cognition to our own? We don't know because we only have one instance of "observers" coming around.
Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by jjoonathan on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @08:08PM (#25204886)
Sure, all of this is speculative, but the eukaryotic jump is notorious for getting casually dismissed on account of being misunderstood. I think it's one of the better candidates for a filter, so let me advocate it for a second and make sure that if you still want to dismiss it's not due to oversight.

The problem has nothing to do with having a nucleus. That's the solution. As you note, it's possible to imagine other solutions. The problem is dealing with gigabytes of genetic data instead of mere megabytes. Typically one would use units of base pairs, but in the context of talking about potential alternative forms of life I'd argue that units of information are more appropriate. In any case, the "easy" strategies suffer from a severe dead end that prevents them from going beyond a few megabytes. Lots of things go wrong at that limit, and while other forms of life would encounter those obstacles in slightly different places, the problem of "simple strategies that don't scale" is almost certainly universal.

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/e4/Genome_s...

Eukaryotes, in contrast, scale.

It's not an easy task. The strategies are highly elaborate and severely intrusive. They touch the most fundamental, highly conserved aspects of the genome, of cell functionality, and of reproduction. Genes have to be organized hierarchically, packed and unpacked, and everything that interacts with them has to be made compatible with that reality. Further, everything must be done in parallel. The entire architecture of the genome changes as a result. It's like a distributed system vs a monolith. It's a tough, deep-reaching transition to pull off, it's a tougher transition to justify, and that's if you're an engineer capable of things like planning, prediction, and delayed gratification! A greedy optimizer bumbling around in the dark can't rely on cognition (or even a hype cycle!) to propel itself from one mountain range of local optima to another mountain range.

I'm sure there are plenty of strategies for scaling genomes, but if they're all difficult -- and the crazy elaborate mechanisms we see in Earth eukaryotes suggest that could be the case -- then they still constitute a filter.

But yeah, this is all speculation. Nobody really knows.

Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by andrewflnr on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @04:30AM (#25207412)
This is a much more interesting argument than the ones downthread about mitochondria, et al. It seems to me to increase the urgency of understanding eukaryotic and archaean evolution so we can get a handle on exactly how hard that jump was.
Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by enkid on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @08:29PM (#25205022)
Certainly everything you say is true for our genetic chemistry, but I don't see a reason why that is necessarily true for all genetic chemistry. For example, our data storage for computers scales from megabytes to gigabytes very well. There's no reason to think there aren't other solutions that scale just as well.
Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by jjoonathan on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @09:08PM (#25205233)
Life on Earth evolved histones, nuclei, chromosomes, and all the crazy eukaryotic infrastructure instead of altering genetic chemistry, suggesting that doing so would be an even taller order. Each emergence of life probably only gets one roll of this die. While I'm sure a chemistry exists that supports vertical scaling 1000x beyond our own, it's not unreasonable to speculate that such genetic chemistry could be rare.

Energetics and thermodynamics are absolutely capable of imposing harsh boundaries. How long has our battery technology been stuck at this order of magnitude? How long have internal combustion and explosives been stuck at this order of magnitude? A long time, and that's with an enormous number of very clever and motivated people chipping away at the problem.

There's a reason why I chose distributed systems in my analogy: it proves that information science and engineering are not immune to the "difficulty barrier" problem. Vertical scaling hit a soft limit in the software industry long before it enabled the largest cloud-scale applications we see today. The transition from vertical to horizontal scaling was painful, but not nearly as painful as it would have been to wait for vertical scaling to catch up. We'd still be waiting.

Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by enkid on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @09:22PM (#25205319)
> While I'm sure a chemistry exists that supports vertical scaling 1000x beyond our own, it's not unreasonable to speculate that such genetic chemistry could be rare.

This is what I'm talking about. Your making an assumption and straight up saying it's an assumption, but not providing any evidence that this assumption is true. You make another analogy which may or may not apply. I'm not saying you're wrong, and I'm not saying that you're right. I'm saying there is no possible way any of us can know at this point.

Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by jjoonathan on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @09:38PM (#25205428)
This entire field is speculative and nobody argued otherwise. Quite the opposite: I bent over backwards to redundantly state it over and over again. More than I should have, and now I'm beginning to wonder why I bothered if it didn't prevent me from being ignored.

The "you can't prove it" objection must be checked at the door for the sake of keeping the speculation interesting. Nobody is arguing that you should walk through the door. It's probably more respectable to refuse, on the whole. Once you walk through the door, though, complaining about proof is a bit silly, like walking into a speakeasy, ordering a drink, and complaining that they have served you illegal alcohol. It's not wrong, but it's also not helpful.

Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by ClumsyPilot on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @08:45PM (#25205108)
If the solutions are trivial, we would see them emerge in the insane amount of time it took to eukariotes to apprear. The fact that they didn't suggest they either do not exist, or are equally difficult.
Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by enkid on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @09:19PM (#25205301)
I'm clearly not articulating this well, so let me try to try another tactic.

The evolution of eukaryotes is based on the specific path that Earth went down. The combination of RNA, DNA, proteins, and other cellular chemical building blocks are a way that a cell could be constructed, but not the only possible way a cell could be constructed. For an extreme example, we could have non-carbon based life. If that is true, then all of our assumptions about what is scalable and what is not, based on our biochemistry simple cannot be trusted. So, looking at how long it took for something to develop on Earth tells us basically nothing about how long it would take to do that with this other biochemistry.

Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by jjoonathan on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @09:58PM (#25205546)
I've made the "yes, we know this is speculative" rant in another post. Here I assume you're still interested in moving forward with the speculation. If not, please don't belabor the point.

There is a substantial body of abiogenesis experimentation focused on reproducing DNA/RNA proto-life. They haven't managed to make anything that self-replicates, but they have managed to make nucleic acid polymers with catalytic activity, e.g. you zap the primordial soup with lightning, you get a bunch of short sequences, some of those sequences fold into RNA-zymes that catalytically produce long "AAAAAAAAA" sequences or long repeating "AUAUAUAU" sequences. The critical next step is to demonstrate the ability to do this from a template.

In any case, are you aware of research that aims to do this with alternative polymer chemistries? Such results could inform our speculation about the likelihood of a fundamental 1000x difference.

Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by ClumsyPilot on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @09:01PM (#25205192)
That does not actually matter - most planets cannot be habitable for very long and stars change in brightness - eath will become uninhabbitable in a billion tlyears. So most life would die before evolving intelligence.
Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by cgriswald on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @10:15PM (#25205649)
I don’t think we can really make this claim. Life which forms around less stable stars may adapt if there is enough time for them to do so. It’s also important to note the sun is not the mean star. The vast majority of stars are red dwarves which, while more variable, are much longer lived.
Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by ClumsyPilot on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @09:44AM (#25209718)
On Earth all water will boil away, I don't see any plausible way for complex life to adapt.

Likewise if Mars was habitable, you can't adapt to survive there now un less you are a subterranian microbe.

Habitability of planets around red drawfs would of-course change the game, but it's not clear at present.

Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by ben_w on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @10:07AM (#25209970)
“On Earth” is the problem with the argument. If any alien life exists, the one place it isn’t is Earth. A super-Earth in a Goldilocks orbit around a K1V star would keep atmosphere and water for longer.

Eventually they too will become uninhabitable, but the relevant question about alien life is not “eventually” but rather “now”.

Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by mcswell on Thursday November 26, 2020 @09:22AM (#25220223)
The article addresses red dwarves, you should read it.
Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by cgriswald on Friday November 27, 2020 @12:03AM (#25225678)
I read the paper. Did you read this thread? Context matters.
[dead]
Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by Imnimo on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @07:01PM (#25204474)
Haha! I don't mean to imply that I've uncovered some fatal weakness (or even necessarily a weakness at all)! That's just the question that jumped to mind when I read their paper, and I figured someone else might know the answer.
Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by Twisol on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @06:23PM (#25204218)
Science is about testable, falsifiable hypotheses. It's important to question what we think we know, and how we know it.

"Argument from authority" isn't scientific. We can simultaneously believe (a) that well-respected researchers from a well-respected institution are capable of carrying out well-grounded research and (b) that research is in principle understandable with sufficient interrogation. Authority supports (a) but does not render (b) unnecessary.

Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by zebrafish on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @06:55PM (#25204429)
I think his point, though not well made, is that it’s likely parent is not the first to ask this question and that the researchers have likely already thought about that.
Re:The Timing of Evolutionary Transitions Suggests Intellige... by Twisol on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @07:00PM (#25204460)
Yeah, both this and the original question are good points. I wonder what the paper itself has to say.

The early bits are pretty readable so far [0], but I doubt it calls the original question out quite as succinctly as it was asked. Lots to mull over though!

[0] https://www.liebertpub.com/doi/full/10.1089/ast.2019.2149