News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by gostsamo on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @05:11AM (#25197062)
If you don't have children, why should you care for the future generations? There could be some abstract argument about the unborn being as human as currently living people, but it cuts both ways.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by rbg246 on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @05:15AM (#25197088)
Do you mean to say you don't care for any living thing but your family?
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by kolinko on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @05:54AM (#25197290)
The point of fighting climate change is to preserve human life on earth (and in good conditions).

If we destroy the environment, nature will survive - some spiecies will die off, but new ones will emerge.

Nature was doing very well when co2 was a few times more than today. It’s just humans that were’t there to witness it.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by rbg246 on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @06:34AM (#25197519)
This is just so human centric surely you can see how caring for all of Earth's biome is important.

Personally, I care about Earth's biome in its current state, and do not want to cause unnecessary suffering to animals or plant ecosystems because people trashed the joint especially since we had the ability not to.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by gostsamo on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @01:31AM (#25206498)
It is human-centric, yes. However, the argument "don't have children for the only reason that they will trash the planet" is broken in its very core. First, because a person making it will have a difficulty explaining their own existence, and second, because if they don't have children, the chances are that their values will die with them and the Earth shall be inherited by the wasteful.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by mariusor on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @07:37AM (#25208551)
> First, because a person making it will have a difficulty explaining their own existence

Maybe to you. I derive a great enjoyment from just being alive myself and living my own potential. Considering a life meaningless without procreation is a very unintellectual perspective in my opinion.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by gostsamo on Thursday November 26, 2020 @08:49AM (#25219978)
You miss the part where the very existence of the person brings suffering through the consumption of all kinds of nature destroying goods. Obviously such person values their enjoyment over the suffering of others. This is one of the main issues of utilitarian philosophy where the attempt of applying universal measures of cost-benefit analysis returns unpleasant results.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by woutgaze on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @07:37AM (#25197884)
How do you know nature will survive? Records of previous climate changes indicate the change occurred more gradually in tens of thousands of years, not within 200 years. So nature may not have time to adapt. Also the living earth may have just been lucky the last time drastic climate change occurred; it's not that we have thousands of earths to exclude survivorship bias.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by gostsamo on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @01:23AM (#25206463)
BS. You had a fucking meteorite wiping out the dinosaurs in a year or so. Everyone who has a tiny bit of education has heard about this. Everyone who has a bit more education knows that sterilizing Earth will take much more concerted effort than a nuclear war.

So, yes, I know it will survive.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by woutgaze on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @06:11AM (#25208022)
We're not talking about sterilizing earth but a runaway greenhouse effect. For example Venus seems not to have survived: https://climate.nasa.gov/news/2475/nasa-climate-modeling-sug...
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by gostsamo on Thursday November 26, 2020 @02:36AM (#25217789)
Venus is like Earth the same way both a table and a cow have four legs.

From the announcement you read only the parts how Venus and Earth are similar, but not how they differ. The runaway effect was possible because Venus had less water, is closer to the Sun, and has no magnetic shield. The runaway effect you imagine on Earth needs significant changes in its chemical composition, in its mass, or its physical attributes like magnetic field and thermal input. Humanity is still far from doing something like that. Weight until we start building a cosmic mirror, have self-sustained nuclear reaction on a global scale, or build an earth spanning superconductor network with massive energy volume that would counter the magnetosphere.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by steerablesafe on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @05:19AM (#25197110)
People care for their close ones much more than for strangers. It's human nature. It's not binary between caring and not caring.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by rbg246 on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @06:39AM (#25197542)
I think if you read the parent comment it was a binary question.

Not disagreeing with your comment though.

Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by gostsamo on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @05:25AM (#25197146)
I mean that not having children is denying unborn people from the lives that they might have for no better reason that this might be easier for someone else unborn. This line of thinking leads to a suicide as a logical step which is rather bad extreme.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by fulafel on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @06:16AM (#25197422)
Saving potential people from being not-born leads to very bad extremes as well (maximizing reproduction). This is not a useful model of thinking.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by gostsamo on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @07:18AM (#25197749)
I agree. My point is that having children or not is the wrong argument. Decreasing population growth is much more ethically achievable by decreasing child mortality in developing countries, providing women there with the education to be self-reliant on their own, and providing them with birth control so that they can plan their parenthood.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by fulafel on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @10:06AM (#25199075)
Rejecting the issue based on the fact that both logical extremes are failures is case of double headed reductio ad absurdum I think :)
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by gostsamo on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @01:58AM (#25206618)
The argument itself is reductionist in nature. No man, no problem. I'm not sure if you are arguing because of love for formal proofs or because you want the full treatise why it sucks, but if the latter, just say so.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by fulafel on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @10:39AM (#25210329)
I'm not sure what "it" is any more, but I think having modest amount of children is a good idea, and people from rich countries don't get to recuse themselves - we have such big carbon footprints. And appeals on behalf of unborn people sounds suspiciously like some of the dramatic appeals to emotion favoured by christian fundamentalists in the context of birth control.
Re:Is carbon capture a viable solution? by gostsamo on Thursday November 26, 2020 @02:02AM (#25217592)
I definitely do not ask people to have children for any reason be it moral, ethical, religious, or any other. I'm not asking them to abstain either. Vice versa, my argument is that having children is not analogous to using plastics and should not be considered in one's carbon footprint.