Re:Google Criticizes JavaScript Benchmarks, Modifies Sunspider
by kragen on Thursday May 05, 2011 @04:59PM
(#2518879)
I don't think so, although I know you've been involved in the open-source community since before it was called that, and more deeply than I have been.
But consider: GNU Emacs was started in exactly this way, as a fork of Gosmacs. There are dozens of patched versions of the Linux kernel, most of which are not worth Linus's attention. Most Linux distributions ship patched versions of most of their packages, and in many cases, their changes are not suitable for incorporation in the upstream. Making a modified version of a piece of software is the very core of free software.
In cases where you want the maintainer to accept your change, it's often a good idea to discuss it with them first in order to see if they agree that it's useful. However, in other cases, it's more useful to try it out first so that you have better data to go into the discussion with.
But consider: GNU Emacs was started in exactly this way, as a fork of Gosmacs. There are dozens of patched versions of the Linux kernel, most of which are not worth Linus's attention. Most Linux distributions ship patched versions of most of their packages, and in many cases, their changes are not suitable for incorporation in the upstream. Making a modified version of a piece of software is the very core of free software.
In cases where you want the maintainer to accept your change, it's often a good idea to discuss it with them first in order to see if they agree that it's useful. However, in other cases, it's more useful to try it out first so that you have better data to go into the discussion with.