This is a thing that is different in GIMP: that the selection specifies an area of the image which is affected by operations, rather than an object to manipulate.
"I did not know another way existed" seems outlandish. I mean, launch any paint program developed for any platform in the last 40 years; chances are you can select a rectangle and just drag it.
There is a rhyme and reason to the way GIMP does it, and you can learn it quickly, but it's going to cause complaints.
It could be that 99% of the anti-GIMP ranting is caused by this one issue.
Your comment seems like you missed what was being talked about. In fact you appear to think I was arguing a point antipodal to what I was actually saying.
"I did not know another way existed" was referring to a second way to do it in GIMP.
I did not know another way existed... which also just illustrates the point.