Rapid testing and isolating (I doubt the US could "enforce" it but you have to give the benefit of doubt that a percentage of people do care for others and will isolate - FWIW, I've seen this happen in Oz where a large %-age of people did isolate) will reduce/delay the infection surge and give time for the healthcare system to recover from the second shock this year. In addition, with the EUAs in flight by Jan '21 (hopefully), this one-two punch should drastically cut both infections and deaths. Remember, in the world of exponentials, both increase and decrease are exponential.
So just do what we do in Australia and quarantine them in hotels.
If you manage it properly it can be highly effective.
well there's your problem. People are unwilling to make the least bit of self-sacrifice for a common cause.
And it's not even that big of a sacrifice - it's just staying in a hotel for 2 weeks, and not leaving! I'm like WTF why is it such a big deal?
First, that alone would be HUGE progress.
"As soon as everyone lowers their guard and goes back to normal, it's going to spread again."
Yeah, but this time you're not going to have whining, tantrum-throwing, conspiracy-mongering, megalomaniacal, science-denying children in charge.
We've yet to see if they wind up being more competent and actually make a difference, but the chance to do proper contact tracing on the relatively few people that get infected will be there, and hopefully the country will take it more seriously the second time around.
I'm not hugely optimistic, but if they actually followed through and were competent in dealing with it this time, it could save millions of lives.
I think you greatly overestimate how politics plays into this. It never ends until we're immune.
You just keep testing people, and do isolation and contact tracing on the ones that get sick.
In the meantime, vaccines will start to roll out.
Curbing this pandemic is perfectly practical and within reach, given the will to do it.
I say this as someone that is fine complying with my states restrictions. I even think they are correct, if only as something to try. I'm just not seeing the end game here. :(
Of course this works out easy in a post. Good luck implementing it in real life. People violate quarantine if they can.
Or did you mean we're all going to do daily testing and contact tracing forever?
A nitpick, but it deals with a pervasive idea that should be updated.
The virus will most likely never "run its course" to give us collective immunity without technological intervention.
That's because herd immunity is only known to have ever occurred as a result of deliberate vaccination, and even then it disappears in areas where vaccination stops. It has never been observed to occur naturally as a result of infection.
In other words, the "natural herd immunity solution" is simply not something most of the scientific community believes to be an option right now. Instead the prevailing theory is that if we let it "run its course" it would in fact continue circulating endlessly, gradually mutating.
Epidemiologists do perform calculations to estimate how natural herd immunity might arise, but it has never yet been observed to actually happen, and the calculations are intrinsically rather unreliable.
From "The false promise of herd immunity for COVID-19" (21st October 2020, https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-02948-4):
> never before have we reached herd immunity via natural infection
Also maybe relevant, if herd immunity could occur naturally, then the calculations done around it lead to:
> proposals to largely let the virus run its course [...] could bring “untold death and suffering”
I think it's optimistic to assume this could be used as an entry check for a restaurant.
In January of this year, there were a negligible amount of people in the US with Covid. Let's say now in November everyone gets tested every day, and you have an unbelievable compliance for self quarantining on positive results. It would never happen, but pretend it's 99.9% of people following the rules to "drive the virus towards elimination within weeks". Great, now you think you've beaten it back to where it came from.
How does this do anything other than reset the clock back to last January just in time for next January? As soon as everyone lowers their guard and goes back to normal, it's going to spread again. We need immunity from a vaccine or from it running its course to be done with this.
What am I missing? Are we going to setup nationwide contact tracing this time? Just a few visitors from other countries, and we're at it again.