News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:British hackers: stop voting for lizards; start voting fo... by arethuza on Thursday May 05, 2011 @08:36AM (#2517096)
We have two elections in Scotland today - the referendum and the elections to the Scottish Parliament. There are two ballot papers for the latter - one for a constituency and another for a region. As far as I could tell (I lost count) the regional ballot paper we had here had an amazing number of parties/candidates - what looked like 4 different breeds of socialists (excluding Labour, of course) and a similar number of liberals of varying types with a group of independents making up the tail end (literally).

If that epic ballot paper isn't confusing then I don't know what is!

Re:British hackers: stop voting for lizards; start voting fo... by innes on Thursday May 05, 2011 @08:58AM (#2517177)
I have to disagree. It's a list of options, albeit taller than a sheet of A4. Instructions: put a cross next to your choice.

If that ballot paper is confusing then you shouldn't be allowed to vote.

Re:British hackers: stop voting for lizards; start voting fo... by arethuza on Thursday May 05, 2011 @09:34AM (#2517277)
That's what I meant - nobody gets confused with what we have at the moment even though the ballot papers are huge and the regional seats are selected using PR.
Re:British hackers: stop voting for lizards; start voting fo... by innes on Thursday May 05, 2011 @11:04AM (#2517630)
Well, OK. It's two 'X' ballots compared to one 1..n ballot. You could argue each way which is more complicated. And I agree that neither is sufficiently complicated to disqualify it.

What I would say is that the mechanics of AV are more (pseudo?)non-deterministic than the Scottish Parliament system of PR. With PR - seats mirror votes more or less. With AV, nobody really seems to know how things will turn out, and even less representative massive majorities can occur. So in a way AV is more complicated in that sense.

I'm still wondering why I voted for it to be honest.