Re:Ask HN: Would free copywriting assistance appeal to you?
by petercooper on Wednesday July 23, 2008 @10:51PM
(#255021)
I haven't used the product and, like you, I don't really know what it does, so I had to write in a very generalist way.
The key to really good copywriting is a back-to-front familiarity with the product or service you're writing about. If you don't have that, you're just making minor improvements to match a certain sound, rather than actually writing something that can push a product's marketing a long way forward.
But! Is it just me, or are the above two paragraphs too salesy? Group decision making is hard, and I don't think a web service would make it easy overnight. Misunderstandings will never be a thing of the past. Pitching should not involve large blanket statements. I'm missing exactly how this web app will do it. In a paragraph. And if possible, why the idea is so compelling that I need to move my team to this service.
So I'm missing how and why. The two above paragraphs sound like blowing hot air to me.
This doesn't mean that I don't trust your copywriting ability. Maybe my intuitions are wrong and lay people go gaga with the above write-up.