News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple M1 MacBook vs. PC Desktop Workstation for Adobe Cre... by KaiserPro on Friday November 20, 2020 @03:03PM (#25164330)
For after effects I'd expect that loads of ram would be the biggest winner.

Personally if I was going to be procuring machines for adobe/nuke/other creative apps, I'd go with a second hand workstation from HP, and give it loads of ram and a new GPU.

it'd be the same price as a new macbook, with less single threaded performance, but much great GPU ram and number of threads.

When it comes to portability though, thats a different issue...

Re:Apple M1 MacBook vs. PC Desktop Workstation for Adobe Cre... by WanderPanda on Friday November 20, 2020 @03:08PM (#25164380)
I have no expertise whatsoever in this area, but I‘m curious: Is there not any timesharing / cloud solution for this? The Hardware you mention would be taken advantage of 1/3 of a day at max, right?
Re:Apple M1 MacBook vs. PC Desktop Workstation for Adobe Cre... by KaiserPro on Saturday November 21, 2020 @08:48AM (#25169700)
Now that is a good question!

There are solutions, but they are not overly compelling from a cost perspective (yet)

For a g4dn.8xlarge (32 cpus, 128 gigs of ram) plus one GPU its $1000 a month (or $355 if you're only doing 12 hours a day 5 days a week, no over night renders source: https://calculator.aws/#/createCalculator)

Thats still $4k a year.

seeing as you need a remove viewing solution too, so you need a machine to host the Keyboard Video and Mouse, its still not great.

Compared to a hp z640 with 48 threads(E5-2673 V3), 128 gigs of ram plus nvidia 3070 is about $2200 - $2900 (https://www.bargainhardware.co.uk/hp-z840-tower-a-configure-...)

Where the cloud is useful is if you are hiring someone for a 3 month contract, or you need to render something fast, as 100 hours on one machine costs the same as 1 hour on a 100 machines.

Re:Apple M1 MacBook vs. PC Desktop Workstation for Adobe Cre... by WanderPanda on Sunday November 22, 2020 @12:56AM (#25175287)
Very interesting! I wouldn‘t have expected such a large difference considering the economies of scale (you probably need to also calculate a small cost for maintenance but that should be minor I guess). Maybe in the end it also comes down to the ergonomics of working with a remote software. If you would have a very good client I think that could abstract most of the limited latency and bandwidth away. Onboarding the data might be a hinderance but considering it is only done once (and also considering the services like aws snowcone) I think thats also minor. Given the name creative cloud I would expect adobe at some point to do the move and also provide the compute for their products (or rather services by now)
Re:Apple M1 MacBook vs. PC Desktop Workstation for Adobe Cre... by KaiserPro on Monday November 23, 2020 @03:35PM (#25191453)
> economies of scale

Its interesting, there was a VFX company that was called Atomic Fiction, that worked on Looper, Sully and a few other big budget films. They were entirely cloud based.

in about 2014 it did look like everything was going to the cloud. Upgrading a render farm takes mega bucks($1-4 million for a large company) so converting that to a pay-and-go solution looked interesting financially.

A lot of high end "live" editing/colour correcting is done remotely, because the machines are too noisy to have in the same room. (obviously 10ms lag is trivial compared to 45 plus loss)

I think the thing that stopped the cloud rollout was how revisions are made. A scene in a film typically will be priced based on the number of people hours the company thinks it'll take +x%. However a film _producer_ will demand n number of revisions to change things. Those are normally not charged for.

So if you have your own compute, it only costs you staff and power. _but_ if you are pay and go, it also costs you CPU rental as well.

I think you are right, I suspect that at some point either Amazon, or more likely google are going to start giving away software with CPU time. (something like https://www.zyncrender.com/)

Re:Apple M1 MacBook vs. PC Desktop Workstation for Adobe Cre... by davidivadavid on Friday November 20, 2020 @03:11PM (#25164411)
I'd assume the time cost of uploading/downloading assets would kill all productivity in the most interactive workflows. Otherwise there are solutions for batch processing.