Re:An Introduction to ZFS
by throw0101a on Friday November 20, 2020 @01:16PM
(#25163193)
I first heard about Btrfs over ten years ago: what's taking it so long to 'gain traction'?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:An Introduction to ZFS
by IgorPartola on Friday November 20, 2020 @01:38PM
(#25163412)
My guess is bugs. Early on they had some serious bugs that lost people data. So the project gained this reputation of not being production-ready which meant that only people interested in playing with a new filesystem were using it. And btrfs has always been brought up alongside zfs which has been stable and mature for decades. As far as I can tell the only advantage btrfs has over zfs is the license. Outside of that, what does it offer that zfs does not? (That’s a serious question, I haven’t kept up with it because I’m a happy zfs user.)
> what does btrfs offer that zfs does not?
As @matheusmoreira mentioned - you can use harddisks of unequal size. I.e. three disks of 4+3+3 Tb in RAID1 will happily give you 5 Tb of usable space. AFAIK, no other filesystem can do that.
Quoting @matheusmoreira further:
> I can slowly buy drives of different capacities and add them to the file system one by one. I don't have to plan ahead of time like traditional RAID and ZFS setups. This is excellent for home data storage!
Re:An Introduction to ZFS
by throw0101a on Saturday November 21, 2020 @11:34AM
(#25170627)
The new dRAID mechanism in ZFS may help with this:
Re:An Introduction to ZFS
by matheusmoreira on Monday November 23, 2020 @12:40AM
(#25183909)
How? I don't see how it makes ZFS more flexible. Users still need to have every storage device installed on the computer before creating the RAID configuration. They can't start with the drives they already have and then add more drives over time. At least not without essentially recreating the array from scratch.