Re:There's Still No Viable Open Source Business Model [video]
by bachmeier on Friday November 20, 2020 @12:52PM
(#25162937)
By my understanding, though, you're not being paid directly for open source. You're paid for the code hosting, etc. You might arguably say open source is what's bringing in customers for your paid services. The problem is that most open source is not like that, with no similar opportunity for monetization.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:There's Still No Viable Open Source Business Model [video]
by ddevault on Friday November 20, 2020 @01:03PM
(#25163062)
I'm not sure why this is supposed to be a meaningful difference. We write open source software and make money doing it. Why does it have to apply to every kind of software project to be valid?
Re:There's Still No Viable Open Source Business Model [video]
by mwcampbell on Sunday November 22, 2020 @02:05PM
(#25180048)
Because if there are software projects that can't practically be free software while bringing in enough money to fund development, then free-software advocates should acknowledge that sometimes proprietary software is a perfectly valid option. Put another way, while free software is good and should be encouraged when it's practical, I don't think it's right to insist that proprietary software is bad and should always be avoided. The companies that abuse the power that comes with the proprietary model are well-known (and thankfully I no longer work for one of them). But some developers of proprietary software are just trying to develop good software while making a living, the only way they've judged that they can.
Also, the hosting business model sometimes leads to misaligned incentives. I don't believe Sourcehut falls in this category. But consider, if a developer of an open-source package makes their money from hosting, then what incentive is there to make the package easy to self-host?