News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An Introduction to ZFS by tutfbhuf on Friday November 20, 2020 @09:48AM (#25160905)
Let's say I build such a system and in 2 years from now, I want to add another 20 disks, is that possible too?
Re:An Introduction to ZFS by magicalhippo on Friday November 20, 2020 @09:57AM (#25160994)
That's the easy thing with ZFS, just add the disks as new VDEVs.

So just to clarify. A ZFS pool stores data in VDEVs. A single VDEV can be:

- a single disk (no redundancy, but same error checking)

- N disks in a N-way mirror

- N disks in a RAID-Z (single for disk parity, min 3 disks)

- RAID-Z2 with 2 disk parity

- RAID-Z3 with 3 disk parity (much slower than other two RAID-Z's due to complex math)

You can always _add_ VDEVs to a pool, and ZFS will start using it. It will try to be clever about it, so for example if existing VDEVs are quite full, it will redirect most of the writes to the new VDEV.

What you cannot do (yet) is _remove_ a VDEV.

It's also possible to replace _all_ the disks in a single VDEV to larger disks in turn (important!), and once the final disk is replaced the VDEV will suddenly appear to have the added capacity.

Re:An Introduction to ZFS by iooi on Friday November 20, 2020 @12:34PM (#25162750)
> That's the easy thing with ZFS, just add the disks as new VDEVs.

Careful though, depending on how you're setting up the VDEVs this could introduce fragility to the pool. For example, if you have a raidz2 partition and then add a single disk vdev, that single disk going down would make the entire pool unavailable.

Re:An Introduction to ZFS by magicalhippo on Friday November 20, 2020 @03:13PM (#25164428)
Good point!

Only way to recover from this would be to either add another disk turning the single-disk VDEV to a mirror, or send/receive the entire pool.

Re:An Introduction to ZFS by rewtraw on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @03:39PM (#25214041)
It is actually now possible to remove a vdev. It's a new feature, not sure if it works for all RAID types, but I just removed a mirror from my pool without any issue. It migrated data off that vdev and into the rest of the pool just like a resilver.
Re:An Introduction to ZFS by tutfbhuf on Friday November 20, 2020 @10:10AM (#25161152)
> That's the easy thing with ZFS, just add the disks as new VDEVs

What are the drawbacks of this approach and why can't I just add additional drives to an existing VDEV?

Re:An Introduction to ZFS by magicalhippo on Friday November 20, 2020 @10:49AM (#25161534)
Well, you can add drives to _some_ VDEV types. For a single drive VDEV you can add a drive and it will become a mirror. With a 2-way mirror you can add a drive and it will become a 3-way mirror.

However for the RAID-Z variants it's more difficult, because of how the parity calculations are done and how the parity is stored. If you have a 5 drive RAID-Z, you can store up to 4 blocks of data for each parity block. With a 6 drive RAID-Z you can store up to 5 blocks of data for each parity block.

So if you add a drive to a RAID-Z vdev, the system suddenly needs to keep track of the stripe width that was used when the data was written.

In addition it's the issue of _where_ the data is stored. If your RAID-Z VDEV is mostly full and you were to add a new drive to it (not that you currently can), then you might not be able to use all of the capacity without further ado.

This is because you can only store one block per stripe on the new drive for redundancy to work, a RAID-Z1 can only recover from the loss of one block per stripe. The rest of the blocks in the stripe has to be distributed on the other drives.

However, there is work in progress[1] to support RAID-Z expansion.

That said, RAID-Z expansion is for expanding one drive at a time. If you're adding 20 disks in one go, do it as a new VDEV.

[1]: https://github.com/openzfs/zfs/pull/8853

Re:An Introduction to ZFS by tutfbhuf on Friday November 20, 2020 @11:23AM (#25161883)
Is there any official statement from the ZFS maintainers on when we can expect the Pull Request (RAID-Z expansion) to be merged?
Re:An Introduction to ZFS by magicalhippo on Friday November 20, 2020 @11:45AM (#25162155)
Not really, but as you can see from the PR[1] there is work being done.

The ZFS devs don't like to push unstable features, so I expect we're still quite a way off.

[1]: https://github.com/openzfs/zfs/pull/8853

Re:An Introduction to ZFS by secabeen on Friday November 20, 2020 @11:51AM (#25162235)
Years. It'll be years.
Re:An Introduction to ZFS by liuliu on Friday November 20, 2020 @10:46AM (#25161513)
For RaidZ cases, you need to rebalance all the strips, which is non-trivial to do online (you have to make sure if the power cut off during the rebalancing, you don't lose the data). Without rebalancing, I think it can end up with weird corner cases (for example, in RaidZ2 case, if you have the rest 5 disks full and added 1 more disk, you cannot write data into the pool because there is no place for parity. It is not a problem if the disks are balanced).