Re:Deliberate Practice: How Education Fails to Produce Exper...
by gatlin on Sunday May 08, 2011 @02:22PM
(#2526425)
You're correct. It relies on good teachers and motivated students. I am still in training; I enjoy my PBL experiences because I have a knack for engaging students; my peers who don't have the same rapport tend to hate it, which is then reflected in the success of the lessons
1) learning is the product of the work Just wait until you get industrial sponsorship of the project. Learning gets less focus.
2)students learn from doing Assuming the students have the initiative to DO. Young people often need leadership and direction provided by a leader type figure to drive them to make the attempt. Else, many of them will wander about aimlessly waiting for a peer leader to emerge -- which may never happen and the project stalls.
I am not disinclined to project based learning; but it is not a complete panacea for the current educational system.